Black Writers get together and share their work. This is the primary spot for black writers to get together and talk about the industry, provide writing samples or just talk about their collective challenges. Anything that might interest a black writer is welcome on this blog.

Friday, June 20, 2008

Resident Evil 5: A Travesty On All Counts



A couple of weeks ago, a friend sent me a YouTube link. He described it as “African genocide.” Not knowing what to expect, I clicked on it. What I witnessed for those next 3 minutes, was nerve-wrecking, painful, mind-numbing and heart-racing. It was a trailer for a Video Game called “Resident Evil.” This specific trailer was an eyeful in the most horrid sense. It wasted no time in capitalizing upon the long history of blatant depictions of Africans as savages and helpless imbeciles. The trailer featured a Caucasian male mutilating African villages, along with Africans. With the not-so ancient history of colonialism and neo-colonialism in Africa, the issue of racial insensitivity and indifference must be brought to the centerfold. This patent-reality must be interrogated excruciatingly to expose the silliness of those who claim the 21st century marked the dawn of a post-racial world.

The Video Game industry is one which has profited immensely from the casualty of black on black hostility. Notable products of its faculty include, “50 Cent: Bulletproof,” “Def Jam: Icon” and “Grand Theft Auto.” This $10 billion market owes the majority of its inspiration to the tragic decisions of young black and brown teenagers. Psychologists Craig A. Anderson, PhD., and Karen E. Dill, PhD, did some studies on the decipherable effects of harshly-toned video games on the minds of impressionable teenagers. They concluded that, “young men who are habitually aggressive may be especially vulnerable to the aggression-enhancing effects of repeated exposure to violent games,” and the fact that “Violent video games provide a forum for learning and practicing aggressive solutions to conflict situations… In the short run, playing a violent video game appears to affect aggression by priming aggressive thoughts. Longer-term effects are likely to be longer lasting as well, as the player learns and practices new aggression-related scripts that can become more and more accessible for use when real-life conflict situations arise."

A 2005 survey suggests that Blacks constitute 2% of the demographic makeup of Game Developers, with Latinos making 2.5%. How ironic is it, that this reality does very little to punctuate the disproportionate consumption of video game products by Black and Brown teenagers. The early release of the Resident Evil 5 trailer provoked certain journalists to voice their outrage over the transparently racist façade. Newsweek's gaming journalist, N'Gai Croal, was one of a few of those who rose to occasion. In an interview, he eloquently stated, "I looked at the Resident Evil 5 trailer and I was like, 'Wow, clearly no one black worked on this game’… The point isn't that you can't have black zombies. There was a lot of imagery in that trailer that dovetailed with classic racist imagery. What was not funny, but sort of interesting, was that there were so many gamers who could not at all see it.” To say the least, Resident Evil 5 producer, Jun Takeuchi, appears to be a card-carrying member of that classic club which pride themselves in being comfortably uninformed of the racial realities that engulf the societies in which they exist. He claimed to be bitterly misinformed of the racial conundrum he had created. In an interview with Japan's “Famitsu magazine,” he spoke unabashedly about the decision to use Africa as the setting for this installment of the video-game phenomena, saying, "We really wanted to show the origins of the virus, so for the setting we thought, how about using the place where humankind was born... We thought we would use Africa, which is now called the birthplace of humanity." In response to those who labeled his “art-work” as racially-charged, Takeuchi responded, stating, “In terms of the reaction, we're in the business of entertainment… We didn't set out to make a racist game or a political statement. We did feel there was a misunderstanding about the initial trailer.” This act of staged-ignorance is the birth child of a “neo-liberalized” atmosphere that champions Political Correctness as a substantive means of resolving America’s race problem.

Activist and, Rap group, “Public Enemy” front-man, “Chuck D”, in a song titled “Can you hear me now” from their latest release, “How you sell Soul to a Soulless People who sold their Soul,” rapped, “Damn if I be some slave again/ Got no fake ass friends and no timbs or rims/ Sure ‘nuff got no designer names/ And I never played no video games.” This declaration of one’s independence also works as a countervailing voice in response to society’s norms. In addition, it hints at a strange relationship between the Hip-Hop Industry and the Video-Game Industry. Upon a moment’s reflection, it appears as though the record producers and video-game producers have co-authored a “3 step mode” to further the desecration of young Black/Brown imaginations. The first being the, “Play it in your mind mode (The Envisioning).” The second as the “Play it with your hand mode (The Experiment).” And finally, the “Play it with your heart mode (The Execution).” I believe these steps have been successfully utilized, with precision and concision. It puts a new face on the old theory of Black/Brown kids being mysteriously attracted to violence and violently packaged materials, be it in the form of music, audio-visual, toys or actual weaponry.

It also raises the grim question of why there continues to be a shortage of positive Black/Brown role-models, on TV shows and News Channels. Recent studies by Independent media groups reveal a troubling truth concerning the role of the media in distorting the imagery of communities of color. A progressive research and information center, “Media Matters,” did a study highlighting how grossly under-represented Blacks and Browns are in the Major media beltway. The study revealed how on an average, Blacks make up 7% of media guests, and Browns make up 1%. This not-so-startling detail also underlined the hypocrisy of media outlets in a time of racial controversies. The study documented the surge in Black/Brown guests after such unforgettable events as, “The Don Imus incident” and “Michael Richards’ racial tirade.”

In moments like this, with an absence of impressive leadership and progressive follower-ship, it is valuable to pause for a moment and question ourselves; what would Marcus Garvey think, say and do? It is crucial that we take his many words into consideration, especially his warning that, “So many of us find excuses to get out of the Negro Race, because we are led to believe that the race is unworthy - that it has not accomplished anything. Cowards that we are! It is we who are unworthy, because we are not contributing to the uplift and upbuilding of this noble race,” and “Action, self-reliance, the vision of self and the future have been the only means by which the oppressed have seen and realized the light of their own freedom.”



http://blackcommentator.com/282/282_resident_evil_5_olorunda_student_guest.html

206 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   1 – 200 of 206   Newer›   Newest»
Anonymous said...

Oh QQ

Anonymous said...

The writer of this article really needs to do some research. Resident Evil is not and never has been racist. Stop creating drama where there isn't any. Also I was dissapointed with what Ngai said. Of course few gamers saw anything racist. Its because there isn't any there. Also, why didn't the blog mention anything about the African that helps Chris? Or maybe the blogger only saw the first trailer and not the second. Do some research please.

Anonymous said...

I forgot. The only reason the Africans look like "savages" is because they have been infected with the virus that has caused all of the trouble in the series. Actually, the spanish and african "zombies" have been smarter than the white ones in the earlier Resident Evil's. Is Capcom being racist against whites by saying that they are dumber?

Anonymous said...

Please, before you slander something because it seems controversial at first glance, please do some research. After three minutes of googling i realized that resident evil is about zombies, not some guy killing innocent africans.

Anonymous said...

By the way, just so you don't walk around misinformed..This was created by a Japanese company. Video games are a world wide phenomenon. And I have a question. What about the people who really don't see the racism in this game? Racism is a perception not a concrete fact. If a person sees something as racist does that mean everyone else will? No. Do you think, if no one brought it up there would be any negative thoughts towards blacks as a result of this game? I doubt it. Honestly, it's about zombies yo.

Shoehorn O'Plenty said...

Dear Mr. Olorunda,

I understand that you may have been shocked by the imagery of the game, but it seems to me as though you know little if anything about the context of the footage you saw. If all you have to go on is the title "African genocide", then of course this clip is going to look very bad.

The clip is from the game Resident Evil 5, the latest game in a long-running franchise of science-fiction/horror titles. Taking inspiration from horror films by the likes of John Romero, the traditional "bad guys" in the series are shambling mindless zombies. The plot of the games revolves around a corrupt organisation called Umbrella who perform bio weapons research. The outcome of this research is a virus that causes the dead to come back to life as zombies.

Now that we have some background on the series, you should look at the games that have come before. The first three games in the series featured a majority of white zombies. This (while owing in part to graphical limitations at the time)was because of the setting of the games. The first takes part in a hidden lab. The second in a small American town near the lab, and the third in the same place. The "zombies" are innocent civilians who are affected by the virus, reduced to mindless monsters to set the stage for these exciting and scary games.

The fourth game was set in a part of Europe where the zombie characters were changed, this time turned into monsters by a parasite. They could speak instead of just moaning and spoke in a spanish dialect. There was no uproar over this, no claims that the game depicted spaniards or europeans as "savages and helpless imbeciles". They were spanish because the plot of the game had this evil company setting up in a different part of the world, once again with the native people affected by it's weapons.

Now we come to the fifth game, from which comes the footage you have seen above. In this installment of the series, the evil company has moved once again, this time to Africa, and once again, the innocent people of the area are affected by this virus. This explains why all of the enemies are black (they are the people who live here and who have been infected), and why they act in a violent manner (the virus once again). The game in no way sets out to depict African people as inferior or as violent savages.

The reason the protagonist is white, is that he is a popular returning character, Chris Redfield, who has appeared in several installments of the series. As the hero, he is once again fighting against this evil Umbrella corporation. Having tracked them to this location in Africa, he finds they have infected the townsfolk as they have done before and sets out to stop them.

It is a science-fiction/horror story, the latest installment of a long running series, not a game about a white man who goes to Africa to slaughter blacks.

Please consider the game in context, without forming a conclusion based soley on a short piece of misnomered footage.

Anonymous said...

Oh for the love of....

Where was Tolu Olorunda when Resident Evil 4 came out and Spanish zombies were being blown away? Where was the outrage then? Where was the anger? Oh that's right, they were SPANISH. I mean hey, it's only noteworthy when there's BLACK zombies right?

This is a video game people. It's a work of fiction. There's alot worse stuff in T.V. and movies with far worse reasoning for it. If this were an unbiased article, we know where this one-sided "research" on video games would go. If Tolu Olorunda spent an iota of time looking at games in general, I believe this would be a far different story.

Ultimately, people see what they want to see. Tolu Olorunda sees racism and genocide. If the player character doing the killing in this game was black, I truly believe this wouldn't be an issue.

Anonymous said...

This is a little ridiculous. Do you even play videogames or know anything of the story of Resident Evil 5?

The characters depicted in the game are not savage natives, but African villagers that become infected with a terrible virus, rendering them violent. Furthermore, the game is set in Africa because that is the "birthplace of humanity."

All the other Resident Evil games have been set in varied locations: America, Europe, etc. The denizens of the territories the game visits all become raging monsters; it is just the nature of the game (and of the fictional virus).

I respect your opinion, but I feel it does more harm than good to just jump on the racism bandwagon without thinking about the consequences such a harsh accusation could lead to. What if the creators of this game are in no way racist? What if they were all black? Are you saying that any violent videogame set in Africa is automatically racist? I think the fact that a large majority of people are not associating this game with racism is a good thing. It shows that people don't care whether the characters are black or white. In a way, you and N'Gai are the ones calling out the unnecessary racist cries.

I am a gay man and there have been horrible homosexual stereotypes prevalent in many videogames over the years. I have not cared at all, though; I know in my heart the designers of these games are just making creative choices to make their games more interesting. I highly doubt all of the people that made those videogames are hardcore homophobes.

In no way is Resident Evil 5 racist. As much as you are criticizing the game, I could also criticize the bias in your article. For example, why no mention of the black female protagonist who is portrayed as a heroine in Resident Evil 5?

Anyway ... sorry for the long comment. I just long for a world free of hate and prejudice and feel this kind of article is just fueling the fire.

s said...

Capcom gave a very fair and even handed appearance to Africa and Africans, besides the zombies. If you don't like Africans being portrayed as ignorant, helpless, savages, you should go down there and teach them how to behave in a civilized manner. Then, maybe they won't look that way when a company does on site research. I get the feeling you enjoy your lattes a bit too much though.

And I see you list 50 cents game as offensive, but not the man who lent his image to the title. He has much more degrading material in his work than resident evil ever could with one game.

I know it's easy to blame others for the shortcomings of your own people, but "Action, self-reliance, the vision of self and the future have been the only means by which the oppressed have seen and realized the light of their own freedom,” i.e. if you don't like it, make your own game and shut your mouth.

Anonymous said...

I love ignorant and racist white people. You guys sound like the biggest flock of asses I've ever seen. Every time you are confronted with your disease of racism, you act as deranged as the zombies in this video game. Why not go get educated on why you're so fucked up?

Anonymous said...

Simply incredible...
Yet another person seeing racism where none exists. I think its hilarious that these bloggers / writers try to drum up a story yelling about race in videogames, as if the rest of the world shares our same history with race issues. At no time in Japan, where this game is being produced by a Japanese company, has there been an oppression of black people. To think that the world should have to bend their views or creative vision to match what is "p.c." in our country is pretty damn arrogant. Also, as many others have pointed out, the game takes place in Africa and last time I checked Africa was full of Africans. I know, crazy stuff right? Please for the love of god, stop perpetuating the racist nonsense and wake up to the fact that people are trying to move past all of that. But when any progress on race is made, some asshole has to pop his head up and point to something as racist or a vilification of this race or that race. It's bullshit and really needs to stop, because those people are the reason we will never, ever be able to move past race in this country.

Darkwater said...

I'd say that thaere's some validty for the need of diversity of videogames, but not doing any reseach for an artilce like this only makes the point fall flat

Anonymous said...

"The Video Game industry is one which has profited immensely from the casualty of black on black hostility. Notable products of its faculty include, “50 Cent: Bulletproof,” “Def Jam: Icon” and “Grand Theft Auto.” This $10 billion market owes the majority of its inspiration to the tragic decisions of young black and brown teenagers..."

wow.. ok correct me if im wrong but isnt the only one being racist here the writer of the article. Surely suggesting GTA and those other games, and hence crime, guns, murder are results of 'the tragic decisions of young black and brown teenagers ' is like somehow trying to say those criminal situations are uniquely 'black' which lets face it, they arent. ANYONE can shoot a gun. The colour of your skin doesnt affect your ability to pull a trigger.

The only things in RE5 he picks up on are that 'The trailer featured a Caucasian male mutilating African villages, along with Africans' . THATS WHAT HE SELECTIVELY CHOOSES TO SEE! again, who is the racist? The creators for making a ZOMBIE GAME (thats already had 5 previous iterations (including Zero) set in spain, and america filled with hispanics, and whites and other races), or the journalist who sees it as a "Caucasian male mutilating African villages, along with Africans" . He is not specifically or selectively KILLING 'AFRICANS' he is KILLING ZOMBIES AND MUTANTS.

In THIS iteration of the resident evil series the virus/parasites just HAPPEN to be inhabiting the bodies of african males, WHICH IS A GOOD AND JUSTIFIED DESIGN CHOICE IF THE GAME IS SET IN AN AFRICAN VILLAGE! how absolutely STUPID would it look if the majority of the inhabitants of the african village were made white? seriously. IT would look completely stupid and make ooh ZERO sense. Oh and then of course the designers would be accused of not wanting to portray black in a video game and replacing them with whites as blacks 'are second class' or something. God this gets me SO mad.

FFS if the trailer showed a white zombie and a black zombie, and the protagonist shakes hand with the white zombie and pats him on the back and then shoots the black zombie, in every encounter of the trailer, then fair enough, he may have a point. but im PRETTY DAMNED SURE chris redfield would shoot ANY RACE of zombie/mutant equally quickly if it was lurching forward to take a chunk out of him. In fact if it ever happened to me you can be DAMNED sure id do the SAME THING.

It cant be discrimination if every race of zombie (through 5 games) has been treated equally. how can that POSSIBLY be discrimination against 'black' zombies. GEEZ this whole idea is completely ridiculous.



Finally...



"With the not-so ancient history of colonialism and neo-colonialism in Africa, the issue of racial insensitivity and indifference must be brought to the centerfold..."

NO IT MUSTN'T AT ALL! I cannot disagree any more with this statement. WHY must it be brought to the centrefold??? seriously.WHY?

Im not trivialising black history here but this ISNT a black history lesson in a game box, its a GAME. Its not meant to be anything about 'black people' as a race, or a comment on 'black people' being savages or whatever. Its meant to be a GAME about hordes of zombies and trying to survive the horror. THATS WHY ITS CALLED SURVIVAL HORROR. T

he only stereotyping is that you are a human who wants to survive, and THEY arent and want to kill you( and for the record when i say THEY i mean Zombies, not black people/africans/ whatever. Just so no1can misread what im saying, because apparently it has to be written in BIG WRITING like a disclaimer for some people who are obsessed with skin colour, perhaps they should stamop it over everything in big red ink stamps just to make it clear. Or is choosing red Colourist to green and blue and would they get bad press for that?)


Just because a game CONTAINS something, doesnt mean its promoting or degrading it. Havent we learned that with the video game violence debate? A game can contain any race it wants to it doesnt necessarily MEAN anything. Why cant it just be a zombie game that happens to be set in africa and therefore features the indigenous race of that country. Seems reasonable to me.

But then again, i see people first then skin colour second. Shame the journalist cannot.

MechBFP said...

Morons like you are why people are racist against blacks in the first place.
Guess what? People die in Resident Evil. Of course its not racist if the zombies are white! But oh as soon as they are black... fucking idiot.

Anonymous said...

"I love ignorant and racist white people. You guys sound like the biggest flock of asses I've ever seen. Every time you are confronted with your disease of racism, you act as deranged as the zombies in this video game. Why not go get educated on why you're so fucked up?"

You know what I love? Morons like you that do zero fucking research and like the flock of sheep you are, follow the credo of blind ignorance like it's your salvation.

Just for the record, I'm a Palestinian Muslim. At least PRETEND like you aren't a total fucking douchebag the next time you post something so godawfully stupid.

Anonymous said...

When will white people get over their ignorance and delusion? You guys don't even care if this videogame offends people of color, you just want to call it dumb. That's why white men have been so god damn stupid all throughout history.

MechBFP said...

"When will white people get over their ignorance and delusion? You guys don't even care if this videogame offends people of color, you just want to call it dumb. That's why white men have been so god damn stupid all throughout history."

I'm black and your offending me. Shut your mouth.

Anonymous said...

''Actually, the spanish and african "zombies" have been smarter than the white ones in the earlier Resident Evil's. Is Capcom being racist against whites by saying that they are dumber?
''

hahah excellent point! i completely forgot about that. Completely fact though what you say, so where does the writer stand on this then comsidering one of his main objections is that the africans act like 'imbeciles'?

Anonymous said...

Before you allow your complete misunderstanding of this game get too far down the road, I suggest you go view the most recent trailer:

http://www.gametrailers.com/player/34647.html

You'll note that there are both black and white zombies, and there is also a major protagonist who is a black female.

Bottleneck said...

I'm black also, and MechBFP, you're offending me. Black people can be just as ignorant as whites when it comes to not understanding racism.

Racism comes when you somehow play into stereotypes that have historically existed. The fact that they have no problem designing a game about African genocide connects directly to the fact that many Americans are not sensitive to the deaths of hundreds of thousands of Africans via starvation and murder.

I would love to design a game about September 11 and show white people falling out of a damn building. Then, we can see how you might feel.

Anonymous said...

@ Bottleneck
' The fact that they have no problem designing a game about African genocide connects directly to the fact that many Americans are not sensitive to the deaths of hundreds of thousands of Africans via starvation and murder.'

PLEASE do some research. the WHOLE REASON PEOPLE ARE MAD ABOUT THIS is that Resident evil is NOT A GAME IN ANY WAY SHAPE OR FORM ABOUT AFRICAN GENOCIDE!!

there have been 6 resident evil games (not including spin offs!), the first FOUR involved killing white american zombies, the fourth involved hispanic zombies (the corporation behind the virus escaped and set up in a new country) and this ONE GAME involves majoritively black zombies as this time the corporation have set up in AFRICA.

FACT People in africa are majoritively of african descent.

FACT therfore most zombies in an outbreak would be the local poulation - african descent

FACT you are killing ZOMBIES not targeting 'africans' selectively in ANY way. There are zombies of other origins in the game too, and ALL can be killed if they attack the player (zombies tend to do this), as ALL no matter what race are equal threat to the player

THERFORE - FACT - the threat to the player is ZOMBIES not 'africans'. It doesnt matter if they are black white, hispanic or purple, they all attack the player , and its wise to kill them as fast as you can, NOT because of their race, but because of their tendancy TO TRY AND EAT YOU!

Anonymous said...

Bottleneck...

Further to what the guy before me said, the developers of this game are Japanese. So the fact that they made it doesn't really show anything about Americans.

Bottleneck said...

I don't give a shit who the developers are. It's not cool to show fucked up scenarios like that of Africans. Again, if you are ok with them developing a game about zombies in the Twin Towers on September 11, falling out of the fucking sky, then I am fine with it.

Get some sensitivity and stop being so damn white!

Anonymous said...

"I would love to design a game about September 11 and show white people falling out of a damn building. Then, we can see how you might feel."

Except that would be an actual event (and one that had members of many races die in it). The game is about a fictional zombie outbreak that takes place in Africa. Are you truly crazy enough to think that those things are the same? Do you know many survivors of African zombie outbreaks that would be offended this game?

Do any of the people who think RE5 is racist have anything to say about the numerous other games in the series, all of which have primarily WHITE zombies? Anything at all. I've killed white zombies for years in Resident Evil games but now that I can kill black zombies it's racist? It's the same damn game. That's not racism. That's equal opportunity. All races can become zombies.

How the hell are we supposed to consider races equal if both sides would accept equality? If you accept that a white protagonist can kill hordes of white zombies, you can't bitch about that same protagonist killing hordes of black zombies. That's saying there's a differences between how the races should be treated. That's racism.

Anonymous said...

I agree with Bottleneck. People should have more sensitivity. A good videogame can be fun without referring to African Genocide. This is a very serious issue.

Anonymous said...

"I don't give a shit who the developers are. It's not cool to show fucked up scenarios like that of Africans. "

But it would be ok if the zombies were white, right?

Anonymous said...

Bottleneck

I never said I was white. Curious that you assume so based on the simple fact that I corrected an error in your post.

The fact that you don't care who the developers are is pretty stupid if you are trying to use the identity of the developers to prove a point about Americans. "Look at those people making that game, shows how horribly insentive Americans are... oh wait, they aren't Americans? Oh, I don't give a **** who they are!"

A final note: if you want people to stop being racist, please don't use racist comments yourself. It kind of hurts your point.

Bottleneck said...

The race of the zombies is not the primary issue. The issue is that they are making light of African genocide. So, if the zombies were white and being thrown off buildings on September 11, that would be just as insensitive.

Anonymous said...

"I don't give a shit who the developers are. It's not cool to show fucked up scenarios like that of Africans. Again, if you are ok with them developing a game about zombies in the Twin Towers on September 11, falling out of the fucking sky, then I am fine with it. "


Ok so your ok with the zombie part... so what exactly are you mad about?

What event in african history that africans are sensitive to does THIS GAME portray?

you said a game with zombies and september 11th would be wrong. I agree.

so we have..

your idea - rightfully offensive -
1) White zombies + September 11th

Actual Resident Evil 5 -
2) Black zombies + ...........?

I would like you to fill in that blank please.

i dont understand what the 'event' is that is analogous to september the 11th that you are so upset about. I truly dont.

You seem to think taht it involves african genocide, as does another poster:

"A good videogame can be fun without referring to African Genocide"


.. the thing is REsident evil 5 has NO REFERENCE to african genocide, in no way encourages genocide, and plain has NOTHING to do with genocide..

so i ask again. what is it you are offended by?

tenno said...

Actually I have quite a few games, where the antagonists are white and I kill them all the same, this game is about as racist as a block of cheese. The write did zero research, and every game example he cited was just as ridiculous. Glad people are jumping on the ANGRY WAGON about it. I'm more than aware of the race issues in our country, which lets face it, isn't that great, but people as usual are taking this way out of context. You want to fight racism? How about starting where it really exists, and not in some videogame, the next in a huge series that represents 5-6 fucking races as both protagonists and antagonists? Gee, a black protagonist? Guess what, it fucking has one. More than one in fact. Whoops, there's that research thing again. None of you have even played the game, so until you have a chance to make a level fucking descision, how about showcasing some fucking patience.

And someone fucking tell Souljah Boy that Ice-T is right.

tenno said...

And PS: People of every race and creed died in fucking September 11th. And people of every race and creed came together over it. Stop being a fucking idiot.

Anonymous said...

Not being white doesn't mean that you can't be racist against black people. There are alot of racist black people, look at Clarence Thomas.

Bottleneck said...

I never cared if you weren't white. That doesn't make you immune to being stupid.

Anonymous said...

So Because Japanese people made a game where a white guy can kill African zombies somehow White people are responsible? Someone better inform the japanese that they are now white. I guess if michael Jackson can randomly choose ethnicity so can they.

Anonymous said...

I like the idea of making a videogame of white people falling off buildings in September 11. I would love to see your weepy bitch asses then.

Anonymous said...

@ Bottleneck

' The issue is that they are making light of African genocide. So, if the zombies were white and being thrown off buildings on September 11, that would be just as insensitive.
'

no september the 11th and zombies would NOT be acceptable. And dont forget. it wasnt just whites killed on september 11th so please stop referring to it like it was.

The point is you are saying that this game is analogous to your example, as it contains zombies + african genocide which , acoording to you , it 'makes light of'.

Pleas, i challenge you, find HARD EVIDENCE about the story of this game that contains ANY reference to an even/ support/ hell any REFERENCE ATALL to an african genocide. You can use the enitire of the internet to find me an official link that demonstrates FIRSTHAND (so prefereably quotes from developers /game adverts etc) that this game makes light of an african genocide, or in ANY way selectively promotes the killing of africans over other races of zombies.

you cant.

THIS GAME IS NOTHING TO DO WITH AFRICAN GENOCIDE!

if anything its , in the loosest possibly linked sense a promotion of 'ZOMBIE GENOCIDE'.

ALL ZOMBIES ARE KILLED, WHITE, BLACK, HISPANIC whatever it doesnt EVER pick out RACE as a factor to target.




as for your comment about, lets have the sme done to whites and youd be just as mad, well let me tell you there have been FOUR GAMES WITH MAJORITIVELY WHITE ZOMBIES AND I HAVENT HAD A PROBLEM WITH A SINGLE ONE BECAUSE EACH GAME IS ABOUT ZOMBIES NOT A COMMENTARY ON A PARTICULAR RACE!!!

Anonymous said...

@bottleneck

Really? You never cared if I was white? Then why did you tell me to "stop being so damn white."

Unless of course when you said "white", you simply meant stupid/insensitive/etc. Of course, if that is the case, you don't happen to find anything racist about THAT, do you?

And how exactly was I being stupid by correcting an error? You used Japanese developers as an example of Americans being insentive, I pointed that out.

But let's get to the larger issue at hand. Apparently, you seem to think that if a game is set in Africa and involves a lot of fighting and killing of people (or former people, now zombies), it automatically is referring to and making light of African genocide. That's not the case, but I don't know how I can convince you of that. I probably can't.

And I have to echo tenno's surprise at all the Sept 11 references. It wasn't just white people killed in the attacks.

Anonymous said...

Oh incidentally bottleneck,

Do you have a problem with the BLACK female hero in this same story who also kills the black zombies?

Or is it just the white hero killing black zombies that you deem automatically racist?

Anonymous said...

If a zombie's coming after me, I don't care if it's white, black, asian, spanish, gay, straight, christian, muslim, or republican, I'm going to unload a round of shotgun shells straight in his face.

Anonymous said...

''If a zombie's coming after me, I don't care if it's white, black, asian, spanish, gay, straight, christian, muslim, or republican, I'm going to unload a round of shotgun shells straight in his face.''

Amen to sensibility!

At least SOMEONE understands how stupid it is to pick apart zombies by race.



I mean look at it this way. Take this similar scenario:


-Your in a field.

-A wild lion runs toward you agressively growling with a sign on it saying 'not been fed in 2 weeks, wil eat you'

- you have a loaded gun.


Do you:

a) shoot at the lion, its dangerous, because ITS A LION (you dont need to think any further than that) and you need to protect yourself

b) put the gun down, and forget that this is a lion, and instead sit and ponder what particular SPECIES(race) of lion this is, as that may somehow change your opinion of the lion running toward you with its jaws inches away from your head, and rather than shoot sit there and cover yourself in bbq sauce and lay on a dish whilst you sit and think.

Tubatic said...

Hello,

Unlike many of your commenter, I understand the imagery that you see. I wrote a blog about this, and a separate trailer for the game (I'm assuming that you saw the one from 2007, and not the one from last month).

While I very much understand the pain one can get form the image of the trailer, its worth noting, I believe that the perception of the game, with regards to analysis of story content, may be different from what one would expect considering the first trailer.

I would invite you and your readers to read my analysis of the two trailers and the issue at hand, if not to feel some kindred understanding on this amazing internet, than to try to find one other person's viewpoint on the issue. My attempt is to come from a place of understanding, if that is possible.

http://www.destructoid.com/blogs/Tubatic/tubatic-blogs-about-race-again-considering-the-differences-in-re5-trailers-seeing-the-sailboat-88998.phtml

Anonymous said...

About the genocide in Africa, who is killing who?

Anonymous said...

I guess calling latin people 'brown' isn't racist at all /endsarcasm

tenno said...

The write of the article, and his lovely supporters seem to have missed the reason that the game takes place in Africa in the first place. 1) that Africa is largely considered the cradle of humanity, ie where every race came from, and 2) that Africa was mentioned in on of the earlier games as where the virus was initially discovered, hence, we have a Resident Evil game that takes place where Umbrella corporation intially found the virus.

Fuck it. The article, the writer and the horrible research is one big fuckbag of idiocy. The next RE I guess just needs to be RE: ALABAMA ARTIC WHITEY KILLING where the terrible Umbrella corporation is making their nefarious plot to toss all white zombies from the flaming depths of the September 11th terrorism attack. It features all white terrorists (in planes) all white zombies (eating only white people of course, there are no people of color in the game) and ends in a mad dash to the White House! Will that make the collective masses happy? Fucking A. What the fuck is going on these days, this fucking celebration of enforced stupidity anyways? I have black friends that are told they aren't 'black enough' by fucking thug lite dropouts, we have people who only scream racism when it's their race on the platter, and now this. Where the fuck were you people for RE: 4?

Tubatic said...

Apologies, you can click my name for the article.

Further, share a similar feeling regarding black leadership. Though, at least from a pride of people standpoint I would be happy to say "this is us, as a people and what we believe" but it feels that we are so diverse in our cultural experience, that if not now, in a few generations, we will be beyond unification as a race. This is despite out common history. It feels that the further we move from connecting to that great gran parent that lived in the south and lived the violent and tangible era for racial tension, we the farther apart our ideologies becomes.

I honestly can't say whether this is a good or bad thing.

tenno said...

I'll put it this way: I have three friends that play games and are black; they were blown away that people were making such a big deal about the location of this game, and just as irritated at how stupid its become.

Anonymous said...

No offense but maybe trying to find racism in everything makes you yourself a racist.

Maybe the images do remind you of thigns that happend in the past but I doubt that the creators of Resident Evil 5 were trying to be racist.

Once someone becomes a zombie they are no longer black or white or hispanic. They are zombies. Race is no longer part of the equation.

I respect your oppinion but I'm sorry its a game about a virus spreading around the world that is causing everyone to turn into zombies. Africans shouldn't get any special treatment just because turning them into zombies might be considered racist.

Anonymous said...

"What was not funny, but sort of interesting, was that there were so many gamers who could not at all see it."

Wasn't it Dr. King who famously said he had a dream that his "four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character"? Funny that gamers are the only ones who don't see the inherent racism you so desperately want to inject here.

We don't see the colors, we see zombies. Do some research on the 4th installment of this game series, and then let us know when you write your article defending Spaniard zombies who are slaughtered by a white man.

Racism will continue to thrive when there are people disguised as journalists, such as yourself, perpetuating a complex that anything white versus anything black is racist.

Allow me to pour milk on my coffee so you may tell me I am oppressing the beans that originally created this drink.

Anonymous said...

I just want to say here, if you watch the new trailer, there are several white zombies present in the gameplay sections, as well as an African woman working together with Chris Redfield. If the previous game was any indication, it's likely she's working to free the villagers from the parasite causing the zombification.

If I may be so bold, attempting to preach the ideals of equality is a noble cause, but doing so where no inequality exists does nothing but make you look bad, both as a writer and as a person.

Anonymous said...

"Wasn't it Dr. King who famously said he had a dream that his "four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character"? Funny that gamers are the only ones who don't see the inherent racism you so desperately want to inject here."


/AGREED !

John said...

Uhm, hello they are ZOMBIES. Not even ALIVE. and their soul intent is to EAT you. What would you do?

Anonymous said...

Lose the chip on your shoulder! You have black skin, nobody else cares except you - GET OVER IT.

Anonymous said...

well lets see the color of the characters for zombies is that they are already dead and want to eat you! hmmmm whats so racist about exterminating something that wants to kill you, and is already dead!?!?!?

Anonymous said...

Weird, how nobody gave a rat's ass when we killed droves of Spaniards in RE4, or Americans in the other RE games. Curious that, as soon as black people are involved, the "racism card" gets pulled out...

Strange.

Anonymous said...

The only racism i see is against zombies. WONT SOMEONE PLEASE THINK OF THE ZOMBIES!!!!

Nicholas said...

Really going after a game about Racism? IT IS A GAME, why don't you do some research about what the game is actually about before you make a blog QQ about a game.

Anonymous said...

I'm sorry, I don't know of any Africans or African-Americans that see this game as being racist. Or are they not allowed to be since they don't? There's only one person playing the race card here and that's the narrow-minded author of this blog post.

Anonymous said...

You are the reason Racism still thrives. You have jumped on the bandwagon of what I like to call Reverse-Racism. This is where an individual of any race claims racism in everything they see regardless if it is or not. Its a self pity syndrom... You guys want to latch on to whatever you can to make people feel bad for you. Resident Evil does not need this...

Lets see Resident Evil 1-3 killed white people in a american town: You said nothing, but of course white people are villans so maybe that is why. Resident Evil 4 went to Spain and killed nothing but spanish: You still said nothing. Now with RE5 set to be in Africa, low and behold its got black zombies... My god, theres black people in Africa? I didn't know that.. did you know that? thats just crazy...

Grow the hell up

Peaceful Pony said...

RE5 = racist? I'd love to hear your thoughts on the 'graphic' sex scenes in MASS EFFECT.

You've joined in the chorus of hate and ignorance targeted towards the video game industry, probably without even knowing it.

Some journalism here.

Anonymous said...

So because Black ZOMBIES are getting killed by a white person it's racist?
That's so damn retarded it's not even funny. OMG White people get killed in videogames all the time. In AMERICA! OMG THATS SO RACIST. Not.

Dustin said...
This post has been removed by the author.
Dustin said...

Who would have thought, African's being killed in Africa...honestly, the African-Americans need to get over themselves. This is a game, from a long-running series where the lead character has been present for quite some time. Obviously anyone who have played a Resident Evil game before would know that the job of the main character is to eliminate threats, and i'm fairly certain the Africans in the game are a threat judging from their attempts to kill.

Seriously fucking tired of black people complaining so damn much.

nsegative said...

I'm sorry but this is stupid. This is NOT racist. Africa is in distress, and whites have been killed in games for generations without anyone raising an issue. Stop playing the race card and get over yourself. Also I like it how you ignore all the other minorities.

Anonymous said...

Here is a question: Why are so many white people on a black writers blog? Are you getting paid by the videogame company?

I could give a shit less about the racism in the game, but I am highly suspicious as to why this relatively unknown blog suddenly had hoards of people all saying the same thing.

OK guys, you did your job, now go get your paychecks.

Anonymous said...

Can not post comment...

how long are comments taking to post on average, tried posting twice in 15 minutes.

Anonymous said...

Stop writing.
You're racist yourself.
"Your Black Writers"
Why do you have to be black writers? Can't you just be writers? Oh no, because you're black you get to be "black writers"
If I made a blog called "Your White Writers" I'm sure you'd bitch that I'm being racist.
GET THE FUCK OVER YOURSELF.
You've pissed me off with this, as well as other gaming community members.

Anonymous said...

all i see in this article is black hypocrisy.

it's people like you that set back any progress the races have made towards understanding one another. i'm black and you know what i think? who gives a fuck about these africans? i'm an american. surely not you, or you'd be over there on a mission to promote peace and education, not arguing for racism on some petty backwoods blog.

oh, and bottleneck, my white friend (and no, his name is not biff or chip) wanted to let you know, that on behalf of white people everywhere, that he doesn't consider 9/11 a "White Tragedy," but an american one. certainly not the way you consider the african genocide as one of color and not culture, even though from your comments i doubt your educated to experience meaningful debate on either.

Geno said...

See...when you word it like that Dustin, you end up sounding like the racist dumbshit you are.

You COULD'VE said "Seriously fucking tired of PEOPLE complaining so damn much ABOUT RACISM."

But no. You had to let that inner racist out for just a little bit.

For the record, Tolu Olorunda, this is not the type of person gamers want representing them. What people are up in arms over is that we don't see the colors, we just see brain eating, flesh eating zombies.

:)

Anonymous said...

"Here is a question: Why are so many white people on a black writers blog? Are you getting paid by the videogame company?"

We're fans of Videogames. I'm sure as hell not being paid, but this pisses me off that he would bring up a race issue about a game that has nothing to do with Race.

T1nd0g said...

Congratulations, you've managed to write one of the most acidic stereotypical ignorant articles I have ready in quite some time. You were not only easily tricked into believing that one of the longest running video game franchises in video game history was based on genocide ethnic cleansing and hate. Yet you also seem to associate with a so called friend whom duped you into this believe.

The only alternative is that you, yourself are fishing for something. Your article and I use this term loosely. Seems to try and gain traction through referencing pop culture, musician/ activists, surveys without sources and a generally close minded attitude were that every single person on that planet whom has a skin tone that doesn't match your own, is a liar and intent on perpetrating some form of Hannis hate crime upon society.

No, just no.

Video games and video game players are not your dog to kick, Keep your hate and your fear to yourself. We don't want any of it.

Next time you want to draw up hits on your Blog, well I have no advice for you, because I could find little room for improvement with this article. It was a mishmash of poorly formed thoughts and ideas broken quotes self loathing and hate congealed under the faux notion that somewhere out there, a little Japanese artist whom knows C++ visual, hates you and your race and his master plan is to stir up hate though the telling of a story based on a country you most likely have zero actual ties to.

You my friend have a lot to learn about equality. This I am afraid is a fact.

Peace

Dustin said...

@Geno,

I could have said that, but then i wouldn't have voiced my true opinion. I'm far from racist, but after growing up among african-americans in numerous states, and then seeing this bullshit, i'm tired of the double-standard that black people are always trying to pull. Yes, there are other races and issues with them, but honestly, this article some of the biggest bullshit i've seen and i'm tired of black people feeling like they're owed something when they aren't.

Call me racist, i couldn't care less, i know i'm not. I like and hate people equally.

Anonymous said...

FU for this topic. every time when i hear someone say thats racist which is very low that does explain the correct facts straight. If Zombies were real in life trying to eat you then you would either run away like a sissy or kill it. Plus this is a video make believe just like Halloween. Black always say its racist just by color of there skin. White can't say nigga but black can sy it which is stupid. blacks don't like to be called black then what should we call them white.

Anonymous said...

why do people keep on playing the race card with this game. throughout the resident evil series zombies have been the enemy and the majority of these zombies have been white. the latest entry is set in africa and so obviously a large percentage of infected people will be black. for fucks sake just let this one go so i enjoy the game without forcing capcom to make changes that aren't necessary!

Mission Control said...

Don't put enough black people in your game = you're racist.

Put black people but allow them to be killed = you're racist.

Do anything in Africa without the permission of the late Dr. Martin Luther King and every other black person in the world = you're racist.

Maybe the writer didn't really look into the background of the game because deep down, he needs racism. Racism is his justification in being angry with others. I think Bill Cosby had a great article about how you need to let go with the blatant blaming of the white man because he's just being used as an excuse.

And if you have enough time to write about this game, you have enough time to lobby and try and support the actual Africans who need help, not these virtual ones. Oh, guess that would be work... you'll argue for them, but not actually help. Armchair warriors suck.

T1nd0g said...

"Here is a question: Why are so many white people on a black writers blog? Are you getting paid by the videogame company?"


"White people"? I don't see any white people here. I only see video game players and we're over 1.5 billion strong worldwide and you my friend are coming right at us here on the internet were we live and want to know why were here? Oh come on now.

Face/palm.

Anonymous said...

I'm happy to see most of my fellow gamers handling this issue very maturely.

I don't have to repeat anything because you guys have clarified pretty much all the facts about the series/Resident Evil 5 to the writer, Tolu Olarunda. With that, I hope he takes his time to read everyone's comments and maybe become something more than an ignorant person for everyone to ridicule.

Seriously, PLEASE research what it is you criticize lest you yourself are criticized. It's astounding how much folly is contained within this article alone--not even mentioning some of the comments backing your misinformed article up with even more stupidity.

If anything, your mindset is what's affecting the world, creating self-victimizing comments. I mean, come on--a blog just for Black people, talking about "African Genocide" in a video game that you wrongly tagged as racist? Why don't you mingle with other friendly people from other races? It's a sad reality, but there's evil from ALL races, but for the most part, there are good individuals out there.

But I see you'll probably tag me as racist, right?

Sam said...

Videogames, like any medium, are expressive. Intentionally or not, when media addresses a topic whether in theme or visuals, certain messages are sent. This is why, for instance, the scene in Spiderman where he weaves a giant web between the twin towers to catch a helicopter was cut. Likewise, Metal Gear Solid 2 originally contained a scene where arsenal gear crashes into New York which was also cut for reasons of sensitivity.

The themes of Resident Evil are not racist, but the imagery is powerful. This is intentional; the game falls into the horror genre and is meant to make players uncomfortable. The problem is not in using real world themes; the question is in the appropriateness of the use of this imagery.

I would argue that invoking an event or history is not the same as promoting it or making light of it. Such an invocation does come with a certain responsibility to handle the material presented maturely and thoughtfully. Resident Evil is about a major pharmaceutical company whom the government turns a blind eye to. When their activities at home in the US become dangerous and controversial, they move their operation abroad and inflict harm upon villages first in Spain and now in Africa.

In previous cases, the humanity of the victims of the virus (the 'zombies') has been showcased; in fact the ending of Resident Evil 4 was a powerful montage depicting the destruction of men, women, and children who had done nothing wrong. It bred sympathy and created an awareness of the harm that major companies often do in real life abroad. It addressed themes of religious manipulation, class warfare, and "scientific" brutality for personal gain. Time and again in these games, the US government acts as little as possible and hides the events from the populace for their own political gain. After playing it, I sat back and let out a slow breath. The games imagery was wrenching, but the message was imminently humane and powerful.

I have high hopes for Resident Evil 5 that it can handle the power of its imagery with similar maturity. Addressing African genocide does not make the game racist or even racially insensitive. Until the handling of the subject matter is revealed, I don't believe the matter can be properly argued.

Thanks for reading.

Anonymous said...

This blog was linked on Kotaku, so a lot of gamers are chiming in on this.

I'll defend Olorunda's right to an opinion on the game. It's very unresearched, but each person is entitled to their own opinion. Also, if this was the only trailer Olorunda saw, sure, I could see why they would think it's racist.

Some people just don't know the context, and all this talk will bring that context to light. Sadly, some people just want to cry "it's racist!"

Let's try and move forward into the future, not the past. There is no racism here. It's a survival horror video game, and while it might make a statement on certain issues (which fiction certainly can), it's a story about a zombie outbreak in Africa. I guess I don't see how that is racist..

Anonymous said...

"i'd like to drum up interest in my blog, how can i do that?"

some time later

"i've got it, i'll jump into the computer game racism debate and talk a bunch of shite, the games press will be all over it, then maybe the main stream press will get in on it and i can do an interview about how i felt threatened on 60 minutes ... damn i'm smart!"

Anonymous said...

Blacks need to stop pulling the race card every 3 minutes. Maybe it'll inform their ignorant minds that the world DOES NOT REVOLVE AROUND THEM.

Seiger said...

Wow the writer of this article is very racist. You know what I feel sorry for the black community. Not because of something I was not even a alive to see (slavery etc). But because people like you make african-americans and any black culture look bad.

I love how people just automaticly jump these days without doing any research what so ever. WHY? I know why so you could get your 5 minutes of e-fame is why.

Because your a shitty writer and finally you thought you had hit the jack pot.

Sorry oprah is not going to call.

Anyway the games is about zombie's you hear me ZOMBIES. Now if you go back in time maybe put down that pencil and paper for a moment because you apparently aren't ment for journalism. Now pick up that playstation controller put in resident evil 1 and resident evil 2 hmmmm most the zombies if i recall are white and move slow and just plain suck. In RE5 they are ten times more intelligent.

So if anything I believe i have more of a right to sit here and QQ about being offended because my race turns into dumb white zombies.

But there's more important things to cry about these days. Gas prices, war, the fact that everyone is feeling the pain of america's econ. going to crap.

But whoa! whoa! instead let's cry about a video game that has nothing to do with racism. BTW THE GAME IS MADE BY A JAPANESE COMPANY YOU GENIUS.

posting anonymous because i refuse to even bother signing a account on this racist white hate mongering site.

Cody said...

Ah nothing like being completely ignorant and then going on to write about ignorance.

I mean, taking the time to do some research and become informed before you throw out the race card would actually make you have to work for your supposed dreams of equality.

Racism most certainly exists that is undeniable. However, it is certainly not the only form of discrimination and articles like this prove it.

But again, informing your self is SO hard, its not like you have a world wide data base to look up facts...

Anonymous said...

Capcom added white and islamic people in the game since there are islamic and white people in Africa.


I am Asian and I have played a lot of violent games depicting a white man killing asians. I don't find it offensive in any way. Even when Asians are shown as the bad guys, we're still coming out on top. *cough*Olympics*cough*

The True Gamer said...

whoever writes this, u should proof read what u write, u rewrote a bunch of stuff and also told lies.

T1nd0g said...

"I am Asian and I have played a lot of violent games depicting a white man killing asians. I don't find it offensive in any way. Even when Asians are shown as the bad guys, we're still coming out on top. *cough*Olympics*cough*"

I LOL'ed my a** off! that was some funny Shi7 man.

Marc said...

Getting heated, mostly people seem to be repeating themselves...

I actually just want to post a pat on the back to Shoehorn O'Plenty for writing one of the more well thought out comments here. Others have been good, but his was definitely pretty clear, concise, and as far as I saw un-offending to all parties.

As long as I'm posting I'll voice my agreement that the series has depicted the slaughtering of European and American zombies in previous iterations, and the local is all the affected the cast of zombies, not any racist feelings. At first glance this is an easy mistake to make, but anyone who plays through the game will see that the idea is not to slaughter blacks.

With back story of the series, calling this racist is more along the lines of saying its racist to assume the majority of the villagers in a small African village are black... But again, I can understand the mistake.

Deuce said...

Well, at least the African American community will always have Madden.

Anonymous said...

"Allow me to pour milk on my coffee so you may tell me I am oppressing the beans that originally created this drink."

Oh, snap.

Anonymous said...

A rather counter-productive blog post this has turned out to be.

1. You're the one giving the people the mental imagery about Black people being savages. Imagery and ideas that certainly don't exist in the minds of young gamers. You're the one who is putting them there. Don't understand? Get a Ph.d in Psychology, or don't waste your life and just see how advertising works in the minds of the masses.

2. Any valid cases of racism are likely to be diminished because of people getting worked up over something as petty as this. See or read about the recent actions of Naomi Campbell for example, and how much her behaviour has damaged future claims of racism.

3. People who are racist are racist way before they get to play this game anyway, so what difference does it make? For example see Dustin. You just drag idiots like him out into the open.

4. I accepted a long time ago that certain types of white people will hate me because of my race. What can they say? Ha ha you're black. I mean come on, seriously. People like that bother you?

Dogs bark, Cats purr, racists say racist things.

5. You can't have an intelligent debate about racism simply because it's an irrational subject. And the people you're talking to swim in the great sea of illogic.

Anonymous said...

tulu is a RETARD. ur a dumba$$ for calling this game RACIST. im arab who happily killed ARABS in METAL GEAR SOLID 4. ITS A GOD DAMMMM GAME!!!!! ur a racist for sayin its racist. ur probably not REALLY black ur just a micheal jackson WANNABE. F#CK U TULU. i'll c u in hell after the JIHAD

Anonymous said...

Those studies you cite? I'd be nice if you actually cited them...

Hard to attack $10 Billion a year industry for it's lack of ethnic diversity when the majority of it's employees live in China, Korea, Japan, and Western Europe, is it not?

Particularly when you frame such a discrepancy in the context of traditional American ethnic groups. Hope you enjoy all of the undeserved attention you blog has now received because of this post.

To me- the author is benefiting from this "Travesty on All Counts" as much as Capcom, and is as guilty of seeking profit by the exploitation of race by being salacious in their representation of the "facts".

As I quote:

"This $10 billion market owes the majority of its inspiration to the tragic decisions of young black and brown teenagers."

Could you paint yourself as more misinformed?

From NPD data for videogame software sales in the US in 2007-

1. Halo 3 (Xbox 360, Microsoft) - 4.82 million
2. Wii Play w/remote (Wii, Nintendo) - 4.12 million
3. Call of Duty 4 (Xbox 360, Activision) - 3.04 million
4. Guitar Hero III: Legends Of Rock w/guitar (PlayStation 2, Neversoft/Budcat/Activision) 2.72 million
5. Super Mario Galaxy (Wii, Nintendo) - 2.52 million
6. Pokemon Diamond (DS, Nintendo) - 2.48 million
7. Madden NFL 08 (PS2, Electronic Arts) - 1.90 million
8. Guitar Hero II w/guitar (PS2, Activision) - 1.89 million
9. Assassin's Creed (Xbox 360, Ubisoft) - 1.87 million
10. Mario Party 8 (Wii, Nintendo) - 1.82 million

Find me one example of where any of these top selling video games' creators drew inspiration for their work from the "tragic decisions of black/brown teenagers."

Your uninformed suggestions discredit the positive arguments you make. If you're going to point glib fingers at people you should at least do a little research, the videogame business is much larger than a $10 billion market.

As it is you paint yourself as a mere charlatan. Hopefully those that read your knee-jerk blog post will see it for what it really is, and summarily dismiss it.

Race can only be a significant issue to those who value it beyond all other human attributes.

Anonymous said...

Give up on the whole racism thing here, we went through it with N'Gai. There is no racism, yes the "imagery has history" but so does the imagery found in the majority of other games on the market. The simple fact is, the game is set in Africa, Africa is inhabited by a largely black population. If by chance that population was to be infected by the virus, the same protagonists would need to go to that location and irradicate the virus not black people. I promise, I will eat a brick, neigh, a fucking house if when that game is released you can show me dialogue like;

Protagonist: "Let's go to Africa and kill some black people..."

Sidekick: "Because of the virus?"

Protagonist: "Uh..yeah...virus..."

Or anything similar.

The racism is not there people, and if you see racism then maybe you should question your own thoughts. I've always said that the people that can see racism where it does not exist must be racist themselves, how else would they come to such conclusions?

Ooh and before someone throws a stupid white man slur at me..I'm black.

Anonymous said...

There is only one thing we can do about this... Boycot Japan and all of their racist products!!

Anonymous said...

There is only one thing we can do about this... Boycot Japan and all of their racist products!!

Anonymous said...

"There is only one thing we can do about this... Boycot Japan and all of their racist products!!"

Lmao, quick get Sarcastic Gamer on it, they'll know what to do!

The Dark Man said...

CommanderHate did a good job of summarizing what everyone is saying here.

http://www.gamerhate.com/?p=42

The only thing I might add to all this is that the only way I could see the trailer as being racist, is if the depiction of Africans BEFORE they turn into zombies is being seen as the negative stereotype.

If it's accurate to how life is in Africa, then I still see no problem. I wouldn't know though so I refrain from taking an opinion on that particular aspect.

Anonymous said...

I agree with the blogmaker.
This game is racist.
Look at all those black people attacking a white man. What type of bullshit is that?
And why can't they attack him 1 on 1? Why do they gotta come in groups?

Neal said...

Hey look! Another blogger who wants to make the news by stirring up a controversy that doesn't exist!

Do us all a favour and just stop.

Stop hounding for the spotlight.

N'Gai Croal and his shameless bids for the spotlight are bad enough.

Anonymous said...

are you serious about what you wrote or your just a dumb person who seek attention?

Man , your really pathetic

419 Zombie Jesus Help Me said...

For your kind attention:

I am Prince Nabu Tse of Nigeria. My Uncle passed away very recently of the zombie virus, and left me a large amount of money ($250,000us). I am very hopeful that you may help me to collect this payment, as I am unable to secure these funds here in my hometown. As you may have seen in your local news lately, a zombie outbreak has kept anyone from traveling outside. I will gladly pay you the sum of $33,000us to help me retrieve these funds, will send as soon as I hear from you. Please to send me your name, address, and bank account number to deposit this money. I will send further instructions for helping me after I kill these zombie bastards.

Best Regards,
Prince Nabu Tse

Anonymous said...

OMG! This game is so racist! What's wrong with you people? Why don't you go watch the O'Reilly Factor or something!

Anonymous said...

I have a very serious question that I haven't heard answered yet and maybe you could provide some sort of response. I've heard a number of people state that "it's not that you can't have black zombies"... well, could you please provide some sort of example in which this game WOULDN'T be offensive and still allow for black zombies? Is it that the game simply can't be in Africa, or that the protagonist can't be white if it is? Is it that the zombies need to be equally divided by race even if it would make zero sense to do so?

Since you're also sticking up for "brown people" in your post, please go back and look at Resident Evil 4. I would find it interesting to see if you are equally offended, or if you are simply more sensitive to this game because it focuses on a certain race.

Just because people don't see the overt racism that you see doesn't mean that they're ignorant, it might just mean that they can understand the situation based on context.

Galen Rice said...

As noted by many before me, the game Resident Evil is purely a game about fighting zombies. The main character is not slaughtering a village of innocent civilians: he is fighting for survival against people who have been changed into mindless killers and, if given the chance, will eat his brains. We can't have that, now can we?

The reason all the zombies just have to black, you might have asked? HE'S IN AFRICA. More specifically, he's in a small village in Africa. I don't think having a diverse set of white, black, asian, spanish, russian, and eskimo zombies in the middle of a small African village makes much sense, now does it?

Granted, the protagonist doesn't have to be a white guy killing all these zombies, but bear in mind that giving the player the option to have any character they want - any race and either gender - is quite difficult to accomplish while maintaining the game's appeal.

And to trump this argument, it's being made by a Japanese company. One in which the demographic of its employees is not 2% black and 2.5% Latino: they're all Japanese! When word of this supposed "controversy" reached Capcom, they were quite confused. They didn't make it with even the slightest thought as to it being racist: they just put a dude in Africa, turned the people WHO LIVE IN AFRICA into zombies and made it work.

If you'd prefer they not use such an under-appreciated locale in their game, then by all means throw a fit about it. "No games set in Africa!" Which sounds like complete balderdash, doesn't it?

As a side note, the examples you gave are just horrendous. You claim the video game industry profits off black on black violence by referencing 50 Cent, Def Jam and Grand Theft Auto? Let's go over those real quick:

50 Cent: A black rapper makes a game in which he is a character who blows away a bunch of people, and you blame this on the rest of the industry? Why not blame it on 50 Cent? Or perhaps on the hip hop culture that embraces him?

Def Jam: Again, a game made up of black characters that is endorsed by the very people who inspired those characters.

Grand Theft Auto: First off, the protagonist is not black here. Secondly, throughout the GTA games, the protagonist often has black sidekicks. Thirdly, it's not about hostility against blacks: it's about hostility against everyone.

So, yes, do some research into the subject. The least you could have done was a Wikipedia search before you started writing.

Anonymous said...

You really do know these are ZOMBIES, right? Have you even researched your stuff before WRITING all this bull?

You need a life, bro. Really, you do.

Bottleneck said...

People in Asia can be racist too. In fact, the Chinese government was getting boycotted big time before the Olympic games for policies in Africa that allowed for the deaths of people in the Darfur Region. George Clooney and Angelina Jolie, among others, have been fighting against them on this.

Asians have the same negative perceptions of black people that many racist Americans do.

Also, notice that in most movies, the first major deaths (from a meteor, nuclear weapon or deadly virus) show people dying in foreign countries. That's because Americans have less sensitivity to seeing foreigners die than their own.

In fact, I bet that if 20,000 people died in Africa and 100 people were killed in the US, the 100 dead in the US would be the top story on alot of news networks.

Anonymous said...

The more of these articles come out (thanks for the Johnny-come-lately write-up, by the way), the clearer it becomes:

Too many black people are just plain stupid.

Have some dignity already. Your ancestors getting whipped a few times doesn't mean you have to piss your pants over every little thing for the rest of eternity.

Anonymous said...

Oh, have you played any of the previous 15 Resident Evil games? Have you played Resident Evil 5?

Then, SHUT THE FUCK UP.

Anonymous said...

I'm not sure which is worse for black people in general... the virus in the game that turns them into Zombies, or this idiot's pathetic article. Thanks for setting human rights back about 40 years, jackass.

Anonymous said...

Oh, and way to go straightening out that stereotype that all black people are uninformed and uncultured by referencing what???? That's right kids.... a rap song.

Anonymous said...

So if this game, made by the Japanese, is taken to Japan in the next iteration and you have to kill Asian zombies, are these same people going to cry racism then? Probably not, if it's not your race, it's not your problem, right?

Anonymous said...

"Longer-term effects are likely to be longer lasting as well, as the player learns and practices new aggression-related scripts that can become more and more accessible for use when real-life conflict situations arise."

That is pretty accurate all of my zombie fighting skills developed from playing Resident Evil and watching the dead series. Though i'm still holding out that they will be stumble zombies, the sprinting ones give me a hell of a time.

Anonymous said...

Personally, I think that killing niggers would make a good sport. This is the best game I've seen in a while.

Everyone you know said...

Capcom is a Japanese company, not Chinese. If you don't think there's a difference, then you have no business discussing "race" at all.

If you're truly offended at RE5, don't play. Nobody is going to say, "Hey, genocide is GREAT!" after playing this game. It's not going to cause any white people or black people to pick up a gun and start shooting Africans (who, by the way, are more prejudiced against black Americans than anyone else on the planet).

It's a story. It is a work of FICTION. It is entertainment, and that is ALL that it is. If you are offended, then crawl under your bed, close your eyes and wait for the sweet release of death..

Here's a thought: THE WHOLE WORLD IS OFFENSIVE.

I noticed that nobody on this blog has brought up the naval blockade against Iran being fast-tracked through the house of representatives. You think a video game is causing you problems, wait until October.

As far as the racist people in America and all over the world go, it's a terrible fact of life... you can't change them, and all that happens when people get upset about something as trivial as a video game is that you lose whatever support you had in the first place.

Relax.

It's just a game.

david pasquinelli said...

first of all, i'm going to coin a phrase (i think): you just got kotaku'd!

second, i'd like to point out that zombies are savage no matter their race, gender or creed. that's a FACT.

Anonymous said...

I consider myself very Liberal. I am ashamed of people like the eighteen-year-old Tolu Olorunda who create divides in our minds where there were previously little to none. Honestly, it's people like this who are ruining Liberalism and journalism in America. Tolu chose to do no research for this article and claims racism merely because the game is set in Africa.

The Japanese Resident Evil games have all been focused on a virus which turns any human into a blood thirsty zombie. Previous Resident Evil games had whites and hispanics in place of blacks. Which races and cultures are depicted is decided when the setting is chosen. Since this installment takes place in Africa, you're going to see people on screen who live in that location. You aren't going to run into a village of Scots and Cambodians. We have a white protagonist because the game has tried to keep the same main characters since the early days of the series. And Grand Theft Auto depicting mainly black on black violence? Please, the earlier installments of the game were about white people and the mafia. There's more to the series than San Andreas.

It's also evident that Tolu has little knowledge about Hip-Hop and Rap in general. You can go back a little more than ten years to find highly influential artists talking about Sega and Nintendo. Being eighteen, I feel Tolu relied on plain old memory instead of actually researching the connection between music and video games; the world did not begin when you hit puberty. I highly doubt that teens were being sold violence via Mario Bros. and Sonic the Hedgehog. I'd also like to note that it's not blacks selling video games through music to blacks, it's men talking about games to other men. Think about it. How many male friends do you know who don't have a video game console from this gen or last and how many female friends don't? The PS3 and XBox 360 are tech toys largely marketed towards young males.

We don't look at it as an issue of race. When it's all said and done, gamers will be having fun with the games they understand. We understand it and we know that the series isn't prejudice because we know the product so well. The only people with a racist thought in their minds will be those like the ignorant Tolu Olorunda. People like you judge a product or a person at first glance. People like you try to find racism everywhere because it's always on your mind.

No, Tolu Olorunda. You are the racist.

Soiled Sinema said...

Are you fucking retarded? Do you not understand that the origins of zombies actually evolved from Voodoo in Haiti?

Anonymous said...

You're fucking retarded, get a life. The game is based in AFRICA THERE ARE NO WHITE PEOPLE THERE. IT'S A VIDEO GAME.

Anonymous said...

If any race lived in the middle of no where, away from technology, education or any other human contact besides themselves and the others around them for all their lives, they would be pretty fucking dumb. Why does race always have to be a fucking factor? If I play a game taking place in Africa and i see a bunch of fucking mexicans running at me, I would be so damn confused my brain would hurt. So please think before you post your stupid, pointles ophnion.. I mean for fucks sake!

Anonymous said...

You've done a rather poor job of researching the topic before forming an opinion. Overall, poorly performed job.

doesnotequal said...

If I took every YouTube link I was sent at face value, I'd have a terribly skewed vision of the world and its people as well.

You're taking the teaser trailer for the latest installment of a long-running video game series and reacting to it as if it were a how-to video.

In the future, please do a little research before putting the "jerk" in "knee-jerk."

Jordan said...

100% wrong, grats.

Anonymous said...

Just gonna throw this out there...
if it was a guy with dark skin killing these people, you would have no problem with it and probably wouldn't have even payed attention to the game.

you fucking racist little bitch
grow the fuck up
when i see this i see AFRICAN PEOPLE
not BLACK people
AFRICAN PEOPLE
BECAUSE THEY ARE IN AFRICA
stop being such a racist piece of shit you jackass

Anonymous said...

"If the player character doing the killing in this game was black, I truly believe this wouldn't be an issue."

It would be an issue. We would probably deride it as another example of the white man exploiting black-on-black violence in the media.

Anonymous said...

I love how the author states that 2% of the game developers are Black, and that 2.5% are Latino, leaving the reader to infer the majority is white, while in reality the game industry is mainly made up of Asian developers, not white.

Anonymous said...

I can see where your concern came from, but as a gamer who have played all of the Resident Evils, I hope you've look into the history of this series of games(not movies).

The setting of the game is base of a parasitic virus that will change humans from within, into monsters that lust for blood. In other word, the creator have no intention of targeting a specific group except for the fact of geological setting of the game's story. As of the hero in this game, happens to be from earlier Resident Evil entry, and happens to be white.(oh, and his partner in this new title is a black female)

In all, what I really want to say is... If this game is located in middle east, Asia or some poorer country, would you still say it is racist towards them? Even though the story revolves around a virus, NOT a nation or the color of people's skin?

Anonymous said...

"'If the player character doing the killing in this game was black, I truly believe this wouldn't be an issue.'

It would be an issue. We would probably deride it as another example of the white man exploiting black-on-black violence in the media."


Of course. Unless it's white people killing white people, someone is going to throw a fit and spew out blogs about the racist white man.

Anonymous said...

You are incredibly ignorant.

'K' said...

We would probably deride it as another example of the white man exploiting black-on-black violence in the media.

Yeah, the JAPANEESE developers who made the game are SO white men exploiting black men. Hurrr....

Anonymous said...

I can't wait for this game to come out so that I can think of dumb niggers like the write and bottleneck every time I shoot a zombie

timetokill said...

I would love to see a listing of what this "classic racist imagery" is. I hear it mentioned pretty often, but there are never any specific examples. If the author, or N'Gai, or anybody would like to comment on this, I'd love to hear it.

Furthermore, I'm a little confused as to why the authors of these articles keep holding up a Japanese developer, populated almost entirely of Japanese people, to standards of "American racist imagery."

Anonymous said...

You can notice that the writer of this article has an African name. These images might be offensive to him. You should probably stop being the same old insensitive, pathetic white men (or whatever) you were trained to be and actually hear what he has to say.

Anonymous said...

R4 had hispanic zombies getting killed and no racist topics came out, yet as soon as the game involves killing black zombies you idiots make a big scene. And IM NOT A PATHETIC WHITE MEN and there is no color to gamers!!!!

Anonymous said...

"You can notice that the writer of this article has an African name. These images might be offensive to him. You should probably stop being the same old insensitive, pathetic white men (or whatever) you were trained to be and actually hear what he has to say."

We've already listened and dismissed. The article was poorly thought out and ignorant. It's fine to scream racism when the attack is due to race, but it's not fine to when race is irrelevant. It damages the progressive movement as a whole when you cry wolf like that.

Anonymous said...

I'm going to be blunt, and honest. I'm also going to offend some people because of it. But I'm also going to be fair.

First off, I'm white. I'm saying that for two reasons:

The first is because it will give you a bit of insight to my post here.

The second, is because I am married to a black woman, and racism is something that bothers both of us quite directly at times. It's also something that we discuss openly.

The person that posted this article failed to realize something: Racism is subjective. Since they saw the video game as racist, it gives us quite an insight into that persons perspectives on races. I'm going to offend you here, but the person that posted the article posted a very racist article.

That said, it's also understandable.

Prejudice is natural. I hate to say it, but it's true. We're going to have preconceived notions about other people because of the way they look, the color of their skin, they're gender, etc... I do it, the person reading this does it, the next person you talk to that you don't know will do it when they see you. The reason for this is because we learn from experience. We might assume something of someone of a particular color, because we're used to seeing that. I see a black male, I assume they enjoy rap music because that's what I've come to learn in my experience, despite it not always being true.

Another note, I never thought about it until this issue with Resident Evil 5 came up, and I had to wrack my brain to come up with an appropriate game.

The game Shadowman portrays a black man from Louisiana who gained the ability to travel between the land of the living, and the dead, via voodoo magic. The protagonists were black, the antagonists all white. The primary antagonist was a force named Legion (a reference to the devil), that took the form of a white man. And Legion's main generals were all white serial killers (which is actually stereotypically accurate). Despite the clunky controls and sometimes ambiguous directions, the game was fantastic because of the atmosphere and the story's depth.

I bring up Shadowman, primarily because despite the strong racial overtones, it didn't get blasted by anyone for it. It's easy to point out the "typical" white supremacy sort of racism, and it gets quite a bit of notice. But there's a much stronger case against Shadowman's racism than Resident Evil 5's, considering no one really knows if the underworld would be inhabited mainly by white people. The setting was appropriate for the game, but all white people as bosses? Who cares though? The game was good.

Maybe we should hold our judgement on Resident Evil 5 until we know the full story. I freely admit. I could be wrong, and the intent of the developers could be pure racial hate. But for some reason, I doubt it.

-AnotherNerd

Anonymous said...

I'm going to be blunt, and honest. I'm also going to offend some people because of it. But I'm also going to be fair.

First off, I'm white. I'm saying that for two reasons:

The first is because it will give you a bit of insight to my post here.

The second, is because I am married to a black woman, and racism is something that bothers both of us quite directly at times. It's also something that we discuss openly.

The person that posted this article failed to realize something: Racism is subjective. Since they saw the video game as racist, it gives us quite an insight into that persons perspectives on races. I'm going to offend you here, but the person that posted the article posted a very racist article.

That said, it's also understandable.

Prejudice is natural. I hate to say it, but it's true. We're going to have preconceived notions about other people because of the way they look, the color of their skin, they're gender, etc... I do it, the person reading this does it, the next person you talk to that you don't know will do it when they see you. The reason for this is because we learn from experience. We might assume something of someone of a particular color, because we're used to seeing that. I see a black male, I assume they enjoy rap music because that's what I've come to learn in my experience, despite it not always being true.

Another note, I never thought about it until this issue with Resident Evil 5 came up, and I had to wrack my brain to come up with an appropriate game.

The game Shadowman portrays a black man from Louisiana who gained the ability to travel between the land of the living, and the dead, via voodoo magic. The protagonists were black, the antagonists all white. The primary antagonist was a force named Legion (a reference to the devil), that took the form of a white man. And Legion's main generals were all white serial killers (which is actually stereotypically accurate). Despite the clunky controls and sometimes ambiguous directions, the game was fantastic because of the atmosphere and the story's depth.

I bring up Shadowman, primarily because despite the strong racial overtones, it didn't get blasted by anyone for it. It's easy to point out the "typical" white supremacy sort of racism, and it gets quite a bit of notice. But there's a much stronger case against Shadowman's racism than Resident Evil 5's, considering no one really knows if the underworld would be inhabited mainly by white people. The setting was appropriate for the game, but all white people as bosses? Who cares though? The game was good.

Maybe we should hold our judgement on Resident Evil 5 until we know the full story. I freely admit. I could be wrong, and the intent of the developers could be pure racial hate. But for some reason, I doubt it.

-AnotherNerd

Anonymous said...

Like many people have already posted, video gamers have no color. We all see ourselves as people who enjoy playing games. The person who wrote this article needs to get a life and stop feeding thoughts of racism, leave it alone asshole.

Anonymous said...

I love how Bottleneck seems to think Africans are on some untouchable pedastal that nothing bad can ever happen to them. Especially considering he thinks its ok to talk about horrible things happening to white people purely out of spite. Fucking racist.

Anonymous said...

This topic is so freaking stupid and I think the blog was wrote for one reason - to drive TRAFFIC (I fell for it too)
Go to the front page of this website and just peruse the articles - about 0 comments on all of them. This post - about 140. Please leave this ignorant site and never come back, I plead with all of the Kotaku readers!

PS - Bottleneck has made himself out to be the most ignorant/racist person on this website

Anonymous said...

Would it make sense to have only white people in Africa, where people are in the majority black?
I think there´s a reason for those zombies to be black, and that´s because most of the Africans are black.

Element said...

Why should we have to hear what he has to say if he's going to spread racism hyperbole about something he hasn't done any research on? He's outlandish in his claims, and they are all claims based on assumption, and have no context behind them.

Resident Evil is a franchise about Survival/Horror that has featured countless zombies in the past. The main character in this game is Chris Redfield. Despite what the author of this article says, he isn't there to kill Africans or raze villages. He's there to stop a corporation known as Umbrella, who happens to be nested in the country of Africa.

Shortly after arriving he's met by infected zombies who are trying to kill him. What would you do faced with that situation? Hesitate because of the color of their skin? No, defend yourself. He is there to stop the corporation behind all this mass infection, and in his way are infected zombies, not Africans.

The one who is racist here is the author as the only one who has portrayed Africans as savages was he himself in his article.

No, I will not actually hear what he has to say, because he didn't blink twice about posting about this video game without hearing what the game had to say; In other words...He didn't do any research or look for any context behind what he has seen.

Anonymous said...

Congratulations. You've probably achieved the hit count you desired when you assembled this article out of half-truths and suppositions. I expected controversy the moment I laid eyes on the trailer for Resident Evil 5, but it would have been a stretch for me to imagine that the "white man conspiracy" card would be played in regards to a game developed by a JAPANESE developer.

I will say that I understand the uneasiness you may feel in some of these scenarios. However, you are viewing that uneasiness in the wrong light. Most of the people who play this game will not be paying any attention to the race of these zombies- they are simply hostile pixels, to be disposed of with simulated weaponry. This has gone on for countless iterations of the franchise with nary a murmur. For those of us who will feel something, however, you do a grave disservice by assuming we will feel some kind of glee or vicarious thrill out of gunning down innocent African villagers. What if we, too, feel this uneasiness? Understanding that these simulated characters on the wrong end of our simulated weaponry, when considered in a 'real' context, are nothing more than innocent people in the wrong place at the wrong time. The same holds true for the zombies portrayed in all the other Resident Evil games. This somehow changes now that the game takes place on the African continent?

The claim of inherent racism simply because a Caucasian uses firearms to defend himself against Africans (who are, by the way, not acting of their own free will) is disingenious. Where was this cry when Leon Kennedy, a Caucasian, was shooting mind-controlled Spanish villagers in Resident Evil 4? And where was this cry when Carlos Oliviera, a Latino who was very likely NOT a United States citizen, strolled the streets of a Midwestern American town gunning down WHITE zombies in Resident Evil 3? I certainly didn't feel offended.

It seems to me that there is an enormous racial Catch-22 here: Depictions of white-on-black violence cannot be tolerated until racism is considered dead, yet racism can never be considered dead because white people are inherently racist. I am white, and apparently to some people that means I am racist... but wait. Isn't making a judgement about me based on the color of my skin RACIST? Or is it okay beause I'm white, and... well, "you know those white people"?

Allow me to close with a famous quote:

"Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere. We are caught in an inescapable network of mutuality, tied in a single garment of destiny. Whatever affects one directly, affects all indirectly."

A man I deeply respect said that. One Martin Luther King Jr. Perhaps you know of him?

John Ingersoll said...

My name is Johnathon Ingersoll, I am a Native Canadian (i.e. Red Indian) from Canada. I am a full fledged Chippewa. Basically what I'm saying is, my people were nearly wiped out and in some instances forced into slavery by white men from Europe. I say this to illustrate a point here; that point being that I come from a similar background to African Americans.

Now that that is out of the way, I want to get to a couple of points. Number one of those points is... what exactly is being condemned here? I want to know after such an articulate article I still cannot see the point here.

Is this game--Resident Evil 5--being condemned by this particular community (that being the author and so-in, this website) for featuring Africans as the antagonists, or because in particular, there is a white protagonist within this setting? I seriously want to know the answer to this. Until then, a little background info.

Resident Evil--the first three games, anyhow--took place in a midwestern town in the United States which featured infected zombies. They were hispanic, white, black, any shade of colour you wish to see. Although it was kind of hard to tell the difference since they had limbs missing and their faces were beyond decomposed. I digress.

Resident Evil 4 came out four years ago. This time, it took place in Spain and, because of that, featured mainly Spanish antagonists and a white protagonist (who had been a previous protagonist in Resident Evil 2--taking place in the US). The villagers as they were called, were Spanish because the game took place in a remote area of Spain. Do we follow so far?

Now I'll do you one better.

The main antagonists of Resident Evil 4 were, actually, white men. Or caucasian, if you prefer--they were men from another land who had come to this small village and taken it over, almost entirely. They forced the villagers to mine an area which unleashed a long-dormant parasite. This parasite infected the villagers and drove them mad, giving them an insatiable desire to kill anyone who didn't "fit in". Savagely, I might add. The reason for this is because the Parasite was in control. The villager's own mind was gone, and as such, they just simply weren't themselves anymore.

Now this parasite, it seems, has jumped to Africa. What you saw in the trailer was an African villager being forced down by Infected Africans. As such, what you're seeing is not "African Genocide" or even racism against Africans. Chris Redfield (the protagonist from Resident Evil 1) is in Africa looking for the people who have unleashed the parasite on this small village. That's his job. To find out who is spreading the parasite, and to stop them. The villagers, from what I've seen, are behaving in much the same way they did in Resident Evil 4. There is no conscience there, there is only the control of the Parasite.

So, in viewing this trailer in the proper context, how is it racist? Because an African village in the middle of a no-man's-land in Africa is inhabited--mainly--by Africans? I don't see the issue, and before I'm attacked for that, let me explain something else.

I said earlier that I am a Native Canadian. That means I'm a "red Indian". I.E. My people were here first, to dumb it down to the lowest common denominator. Very few peoples have experienced the atrocities that were committed against my people, and my nation. We were poisoned by small pox, our lands were invaded, our game was taken, we were either killed, forced west, or enslaved. We were seen as savages by the European white man. I say this because there is a game that is--although primitive--makes light of my people's situation. It is a truly racist game. It is for the Atari 26 or 2800, and it is called "Custer's Revenge". It's about the very same Custer who raped and pillaged tribes of my people and, the game ends in fact, with the rape of an Indian woman. While it may be laughable nowadays (and in fact, actually is), it is still a sensitive subject that, much like the depiction of a white man beating or killing a black man is, a touchy subject. However, I'd also like to point something out.

Nobody complained about that. Every time you see a film or a piece of literature where the American Cowboy is the hero and the Indian is the villain, nobody says a word. Sure, you see a few people here and there complaining with self-righteous indignation, but of the majority, nobody cares.

I say this here, because like that game and literature and films before it, the majority doesn't care. When they see a videogame, when they see a piece of literature, or they see a film, they view it first as entertainment, and analytically view it second. Is there a hidden message in Resident Evil 5? Is it telling everyone it's okay to slaughter Africans? I don't think so, but because it's a trailer and you (the author) are unaware of the context it's presented in, I think that leaves a lot up to personal interpretation.

We will always see things the way we want to. We will perceive racism when in fact, there isn't any. We will perceive sexual themes or disturbing imagery as such simply because our minds are trying to process the data and classify it. Basically, when we are unaware of context, our minds go to work trying to put something within a certain framework or context. Whatever we think about, whatever is deeply rooted inside our minds, we will perceive. As you see, it becomes a form of guesswork, and that is where I feel that this perceived prejudice is coming from.

I'm sure many here have stated "Oh it's just a game" or "You don't understand the context" or "It's just logical. African village = Africans predominant". Whatever the case may be, the author here has taken images which are, to the uninitiated, ambiguous, and has put a racist spin onto them. I feel it is because of that ambiguity that the author has perceived the game as a racial degradation of Africans.

I plead with you, sir, to wait and see for yourself. It is entirely unfair to condemn this material without seeing it within the context it was meant for. And, as I'm fond of saying, ignorance is no excuse. Research next time, and you may find that the Racial Hocus-Pocus your mind framed this piece of material in, will not hold much, if any, weight.

Anonymous said...

This is one of the most ignorant things I have read so far this week. To read racism into a Resident Evil game, would be like reading it into a Mario Bros game. You need to grow up, get a life, and realize games are games. Are you going to take up the cause against spanish racism due to Resident Evil 4?

Anonymous said...

"Simply incredible...
Yet another person seeing racism where none exists. I think its hilarious that these bloggers / writers try to drum up a story yelling about race in videogames, as if the rest of the world shares our same history with race issues. At no time in Japan, where this game is being produced by a Japanese company, has there been an oppression of black people. To think that the world should have to bend their views or creative vision to match what is "p.c." in our country is pretty damn arrogant. Also, as many others have pointed out, the game takes place in Africa and last time I checked Africa was full of Africans. I know, crazy stuff right? Please for the love of god, stop perpetuating the racist nonsense and wake up to the fact that people are trying to move past all of that. But when any progress on race is made, some asshole has to pop his head up and point to something as racist or a vilification of this race or that race. It's bullshit and really needs to stop, because those people are the reason we will never, ever be able to move past race in this country."

Wow, dude. I'm black and I've been waiting for black people to do this for years. As long as it's out in the open, we will never get past it. Once we reach the point in time where ignorant people don't look for race in everything they see, we will be a better society.

Figge said...

Okay i just spend the last 1 ½ hours reading the article and all the comments, i have to say i agree with about 95% of all the people who posted comments here, you can guess who i don't agree with. the only real racist i can find on this blogg is Tolu Olorunda who did a wonderful job of fueling peoples hatred, his ignorance probably set us back 10 years... Thank you.

hope i never have to come back here againg.

Anonymous said...

Funny, I keep thinking back to Resident Evil 4. It was a bestseller and one of the most highly acclaimed games of all time, yet I found not a trace of controversy regarding race considering the game had a white protagonist fighting hordes of European Hispanic enemies, albeit infected by a mind-controlling parasite.

That made sense because the game took place in Spain, so naturally there would be quite a few Spanish infected by the parasite. And what happens when an African village becomes the site of a zombie epidemic? Africans are going to be infected.

The main point here is zombie is a zombie, no matter where they come from or what color their skin is. No one in the right mind is going to turn the safety on when confronted with a zombie just because of the color of their skin.

African genocide? No. Zombie genocide? You could say that. But it's hard to be offended by that when zombies are more concerned with eating your brain then writing misinformed blogs.

Anonymous said...

This horde of rage was very amusing to read... I have to agree with all the posters here saying that the race is a non issue to a gamer... until Chris Redfield shouts "FUCKING NIGGERS" I don't think this game would be racist. Calm the fuck down...

Epe said...

You do realize that Chuck D was in Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas, right? He was the DJ for 'Throwback FM'

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_Theft_Auto:_San_Andreas#Characters

Existence precedes essence.

Anonymous said...

The enemies in the Resident Evil series are all zombies! They have been white, black, European, Asian, etc.

It has nothing to do with racism. These Africans have been turned into zombies and it's Chris's (the main character of RE5) job to get to the bottom of what is causing thise 'zombification'.
Did you know Chris's partner is a black African woman names Sheva? No, I bet you didn't.
You clearly didn't bother doing any research on the game. You just saw a white guy shooting black guys and assumed it was racist, DESPITE THE FACT THAT HIS PARTNER IS BLACK AND THERE ARE ALSO WHITE ENEMIES IN THE GAME! Try doing some research next time. You won't look like such a fool then.

Anonymous said...

LOL. I bet that half of you work for the company. You're probably 3 or 4 people commenting over and over again. I've never seen a blog where all the comments sounded so identical.

Anonymous said...

This is what happens when non-gamers look at something they have ABSOLUTELY no clue about, they are ZOMBIES caused by a VIRUS, there has been MANY RESIDENT EVIL GAMES, DO SOME RESEARCH. The last one had Spaniards with the virus, games BEFORE that had WHITE zombies, this game takes place in AFRICA, WHO IS THE MAJORITY THERE? COME ON WITH THIS RACE BS! It was ok when others were the zombies but now all of a sudden, africans are the zombies, OH complaints, al sharpton and more nonsense. Games should just leave all cry baby groups out of all games.

Anonymous said...

I believe that both sides have a point here. for one, yes it is just a video game, and no, the Japanese developers had no racist undertones in creating the game. However, the Japanese developers can be seen as insensitive to world-wide issues, because the trailer does conjure up images of genocide. Yeah, they are zombies and yeah it makes sense with the plot of the game.
However, at the same time, would a child that was raised in Africa and seen some of the violence first-hand be able to play this game with the same mind set as an american kid? You can say that the japanese developers are not racist, but they are definitely insensitive. i can say being half japanese and living in japan that if some foreign developers created a game of kamikaze pilots flying planes into battleships, it would rustle quite a few feathers in japan too.

Anonymous said...

Quote: "LOL. I bet that half of you work for the company. You're probably 3 or 4 people commenting over and over again. I've never seen a blog where all the comments sounded so identical."



No. We're just all Resident Evil fans who are sick and tired of people slamming this game for racism when the original reporters clearly have no idea what the game is about. The Resident Evil series is a well known horror series whose main antagonists are mindless violent zombies. (It's like Japanese horror series being known for ghosts with long, black hair).
We, as fans, can clearly see the blog poster has not done her/his homework on Resident Evil because she/she obviously doesn't know the series' themes.
We are merely correcting her/him on that.

Anonymous said...

RACE CARD RACE CARD RACE CARD

That is all you "people" can say.

I do not mean "people" in a racist way, but I bet that is the FIRST thing you thought of.

Rather than me saying "black", "African-American", "colored" people, I just said PEOPLE.

Of course, being racist against EVERYONE else, the first thing you think of when someone says "you people" is that they are racist against you.

90% of my friends are black, but none have ever played the race card because they are understanding and sensible to these situations.

They know that some people are racist, some are not. They accept things for what they are.

Stop pulling the race card, you pathetic fool. Not everyone is against black people

Bolap said...

People like this author piss me off. Onto the video game first though...

I heard about this race issue a while ago and though it was stupid and would probably boil down. Clearly not. This issue is so entirely ridiculous. As everyone else has pointed out, this is quite possibly the first time in an RE game that black people have ever been the focus. For all we know this is the fist time they've appeared at all. The last game had Hispanic people and no one cared at all. The Hispanic people were smart enough to realise that it wasn't racist at all, the game just changed setting into a Spanish town somewhere and therefore it made sense that the zombies would be Spanish people. This game is in Africa and you know... I think it makes sense that most of the people are black. Sure there are all kinds of people there but I think it's safe to say that a majority of the population in Africa is black.

Back to why I hate people like you. You make me ashamed of half my heritage. Why the hell would I want to be lumped with a bunch dumb asses who do nothing but bitch about racism where about 90% of the time, it doesn't exist. It's become a joke for me whenever someone does something I say "it's cus I'm half-black isn't it?" and we all laugh and continue along. That is the only time I ever say black when referring to myself. I always say half-african cus black in my mind relates back to the few black people here in North America that say that they are trying to defeat racism when they are actually more racist than anyone I have ever encountered or heard about. Not everyone is out to get you, the world has changed, now it's time for you to do the same. Stop nit picking through every little thing and try letting people live.

We're not off the hook yet though guys. Since there is now a black female protagonist, the game is now making light of the Genocide that took place in Rwanda between the Tutsis and the Hutus. Oh dear god if that woman is either one this man is gonna jump on yet another hatred band wagon and a little part of me will die.

Before anyone calls me racist whitey. I'm half-canadian (my mother is from Quebec with European and Native ancestry) and half-Africa(My father is from Cameroun). That makes me a second generation African. And I'm very in touch with my roots. I've visited Africa and Cameroun many times, and I've visited the village that my father is from.

I'd like to see how people respond to this.

Anonymous said...

Previous Resident Evil games have had Asian and Black characters killing white zombies. Was it racist then?

Anonymous said...

Wow. So, a game set in Africa is not to have black people in it? I see. I guess the creators of the franchise must hate white people as well, because all of their previous games have focused on the slaughtering of hundreds of zombie-fied white folks. They must have a special place in their hearts for their hatred of Hispanics as well, considering their last game was based in Spain. Face it guys, the Japs hate everyone, black, white, and brown.

Anonymous said...

If a person knows nothing about the Resident Evil series then the RE5 trailer would look very racist.

But the key to these things is knowing what you are talking about and researching it first. You must look into the series. If it is "Resident Evil 5" then that means there are 4 other games before it. The first question you should have asked yourself is "why has this racism issue only just come up if there are 4 other games in the series?" The issue hasn't come up because the series isn't about racial hate.

Anonymous said...

In trying to make some sort of semi-intelligent article, you come off as themost ignorant of all. So they are in Africa, what kind of zombies did you expect them to depict? I bet if it wasnt in Africa, youd find some way to complain about how there are no black people depicted. Where were you when it was white people, Spanish people getting killed in the game? Oh but suddenly its BLACK people, can't have that, must be racist! no matter what the context!

Anonymous said...

It's not in Capcom's interest to promote a ridiculous social statement in a game about zombies.

Get a fucking clue you knee-jerk reactionist.


PEOPLE LIKE YOU ARE THE TRUE RACISTS IN THIS WORLD!

Anonymous said...

Can't wait for photoshop KKK pics of Chris... Chris is gonna get you and hang you...

What?

OH NOES HE IS KILLING WHITES ONLY IN THAT GAME, I WILL BLOG IT ON YOUR WHITE WRITERS ABOUT HOW THIS GAME IS SO RACIST... OH WAIT.

Anonymous said...

Tolu, might I direct you to Resident Evil 5's most recent trailer:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IxZgIEZYxg8

As you can see, the entire African village is no longer human. Everyone has been turned into zombies ... humans, pets, wildlife ... Everything!

The only two humans are Chris (the white guy) and Sheva (the black girl).

Anonymous said...

You're a fucking idiot, do some research on the game before you blog about it

Anonymous said...

i found out about this from gamepolitics.com
People wondering why this has exploded need to realize that there are people who report on articles like these. When we disagree with it we also voice our opinions.

ALso my name on here is father_anderson but i cant sign into my account for some odd reason.

Travis said...

Dear Tolu,

I'm not sure where to start this and I'm not convinced you will actually even read these comments. I think several talking points in your article (which I graciously read) should be commented on as you have made egregiously falsified claims.

First off, I think it's worth noting that the name of the game is in fact "Resident Evil 5" the five in the title means something. Resident evil is one of the highest selling longest running franchises in gaming history that is still going. And seemingly contrary to your belief the game wasn't created with a sole purpose of depicting genocide in Africa.

So far the games franchise has taken place in a typically "American" environment and additionally in Spain. But really at issue here is the moving of the venue. For those who have played the game franchise, you would know that the "depiction" of the zombies in the game is no different than the depiction of the 'zombies' in the other franchise with one exception. In this one they have a different skin color. Your claim that the producers of the games (hereafter referred to as "they") are depicting blacks as the "savage and helpless imbeciles" is groundless. It is depicting the Africans as zombies.

While you make the claim that this isn't to say that making a zombie related game in Africa is bad. Yet, the ONLY difference between this iteration of Resident evil and the 7 that have come before it is that the zombies are black instead of white and it's in Africa instead of the US or Spain.

Furthermore, the 'allegation' that "no black people worked on this game" is an obvious one, as it was produced with an almost entirely Japanese team. Though you didn't mention an equally important allegation "no white people worked on this game." Unlike the other games that you depicted as exploiting black culture, RE5 was produced in Japan, by Japanese people.

Perhaps it was produced with ignorance of some of the realities of Africa's imperialist past, but that is the only real allegation that could be made.

Anonymous said...

After reading these comments for the past 2 hours I realized that the author has made the world that much more racist for the rest of us. Your race-seeking mentality and the ability to find hate in something that is both factually accurate as well as wholly probable is astounding.

Thank you for keeping racism alive so future generations will never know what it's like to grow up without racism.

You're a disgusting human being and you should be ashamed of yourself.


On a less serious note, all you racist assholes can stop lumping us in with the likes of this hate monger. We hate hime more than you do.

steven said...

The game is Resident Evil 5 and it's about Zombies. A virus that infects people. Maybe next time you shouldn't write an article about something you know nothing about.

Anonymous said...

Hey writer, did you ever think the reason that more black/brown people are not in the media, government, etc is because there just is not many good enough blacks to fill those roles?

I mean black kids dont seem to care, it's kids making kids. Or crime, drugs, 'street cred' etc. There is this culture among blacks that fosters this.

Black parent(s) since they were raised like this raise their own kids like this, and the cycle continues.

Then you have the final dirty secret among blacks. You know what it is.

When a black person 'makes it' in the world, say becomes a teacher, or a cop, they are treated different by the black community - they are now 'white blacks'. Blacks who are doing white peoples jobs, and to the rest of the blacks they have 'sold out'.

It is so bad that 'making it' in the real world, being a man and staying with the kid you fathered, and the women you made the child with, getting a good job, etc is looked upon as 'not being 'true' black anymore.

Don't deny it.

Anonymous said...

Misinformation is the greatest tools racists can use. A racist is not a "white person;" a racist is someone who goes to watch a trailer for a video game and is completely appalled by the "genocide" occurring in it.

I do not see you showing your outrage for the Aliens being subjected to genocide in Halo. Nor do I see you preaching against the extinction of the entire human race in Advent Rising.

You have taken a trailer completely out of context. Not to mention Googled studies and statistics that would support your claim, completely bypassing the ones that would counter it. Sadly, that is racism itself. When you try to preach about the fictional killing of one race to stir hate against another.

Anonymous said...

This blog post is nothing short of an epic failure. This reminds me of that review for RE4 in which the guy said he was annoyed by "Zombie talk" which actually turned out to be spanish. That review in itself is way more offensive than whatever Capcom could cook up.

If I was the kind of idiot that would post something this stupid then I'd apologize to anyone who read it and then take it down so that no one has to read it again.

There is a lesson in this. Think back to the whole Mass Effect fiasco with that author. I'm sure she'll never comment about a game she's never played.

Anonymous said...

This just in: Resident Evil 0 to 4 all Black-Supremacist games, with the rampant slaughter of White Zombies.

RSPCA to investigate the slaying of Zombie Dogs and incredibly oversized spiders.

Connor said...

"I agree with the blogmaker.
This game is racist.
Look at all those black people attacking a white man. What type of bullshit is that?
And why can't they attack him 1 on 1? Why do they gotta come in groups?"
-I had to repost that because I almost fell off my chair.

"To say the least, Resident Evil 5 producer, Jun Takeuchi, appears to be a card-carrying member of that classic club which pride themselves in being comfortably uninformed of the racial realities that engulf the societies in which they exist."
The racial realities of the sociaty that Jun Takeuchi exists in is: 98% Japanese, 1.5% Chinese, and less than 0.001% of African stock.
I really doubt he is conspiring with the music industry to further the 'desecration of young Black/Brown imaginations.'

Ignoring the RE5 aspect of this article, the rest of it is... Strange. I don't think the author is the best reperesntitive of the the Black community, and shouldn't be on this site.

Anonymous said...

Wow, you are so bent on picking up racism that your entire judgment has been blinded. Resident Evil has always been, and forever will be, based on one Character killing zombies. In all previous zombies you were a white guy, or girl, and you killed white people. But oh no, God forbid. You have a game set in Africa, where it is vastly prominently (like 99%) black, and sparks of racism come out. Seriously. STFU. The game isn't even out yet, it was a trailer, and you are already jumping to conclusions. Also, did you know that the makers of this game are form Japan. That's right. You are accusing that "yellow" people prefer "white" people over "black" people. I know I am only 18 and have not lived in the era of extreme racism, but wow. It seems that the only people who yell racist are those that wont get with the times and look around.

KREEPYKRAWLLY said...

Your stupidity irritates me. You are blowing this out of proportion, with the "so-called education" you black writers say you have, and i am proud that you do not speak for the whole "black race", you should know that this is only a game.

If you are familiar with the japanese culture, you would know that they (i.e. the japanese) do not see "racism". They only need to be briefed on how western culture would perceive their game. If you want to experience "EXTREME RACISM", i think your buddies and yourself are on a witchhunt, spend three weeks on XBOX live.

For an educated black individual, i assume you are educated, coming to a conclusion like you have, doesn't and will not help out, any racially aggressive issues. If you want to learn more about the gaming industry and races i recommend having an interview with "N'Gai Croal".

Compared with the "porch monkey" statements ( and the unnecessary quotations of great black leaders. Whom i believe if well educated about the gaming industry would understand where the creators of the RES5 are coming from ) that you have made, he has got more of an authentic educated black attitude.

Finally, if you are really educated, you would notice that i refered to your statements as "PORCH MONKEY" and not your race.

Anonymous said...

I sincerely hope this was just a shock article looking to stir up some overblown controversy, because otherwise the author is just plain ignorant, shallow and perhaps functionally retarded. There's nothing else to be said. The author doesn't have a clue what he's writing about and therefore should never have written in the first place. If you want hot, steamy racism to write about, why don't you focus on rap music which glorifies crime and murder in the black community.

Anonymous said...

Being a gamer I know I am biased on this issue, but I do have an assumption that I'd like to question, and a point I'd like to make.

You said: “In terms of the reaction, we're in the business of entertainment… We didn't set out to make a racist game or a political statement. We did feel there was a misunderstanding about the initial trailer.” This act of staged-ignorance is the birth child of a “neo-liberalized” atmosphere that champions Political Correctness as a substantive means of resolving America’s race problem.

How do you know this is an act of 'staged-ignorance' rather than a genuine mistake?

Furthermore, there are good black role models in video games. Alex and Eli Vance from the Half Life 2 Series spring to mind. Another example is Peter Stillman from Metal Gear Solid 2.

Even if this game intentionally used racist imagery, you should not levy that charge against the industry as whole. That are argument would be non sequitur. You wouldn't blame the music industry as a whole if a songwriter released a racist album, would you?

At the end of the day the video game genre is just a medium of expression, and can be used for both art and entertainment, as with any other medium of expression - to say otherwise you would have to show that there is something special about the medium of video games that distinguish them from other forms of expression in a way that prevent them from being forms of art.

Anonymous said...

The use of the image in the article... did the blogger get the rights from capcom to use their copyrighted material?

Anonymous said...

Before you blow your top about racism, please go through the entire resident evil series, then it might make sense to you. You are similar to that Cooper Lawrence on Fox who commented about the 'sex-scenes' in a game when she had absolutely no idea what the hell she was talking about.
Do some proper research before you blog such shit

Anonymous said...

@T1ND0G

"White people"? I don't see any white people here. I only see video game players and we're over 1.5 billion strong worldwide and you my friend are coming right at us here on the internet were we live and want to know why were here? Oh come on now.

Face/palm."



100% correct! Go T1ND0G! i hate all these 'its a conspiracy', and 'are you getting paid to disagree by the vidya games industry'. No we are just GAMERS. (not white, black , pink , or polka dot, just GAMERS) and when you attack something we are passionate about we will defend it.

Anonymous said...

I understand where you are coming from. If you have no previous knowledge of RE gams then the RE5 trailer could easily be mistaken as a racist game. But you really should have researched the game before posting this blog because, as you can see by the above comments, RE5 has nothing to do with racism.

Most people just play the game to shoot up zombies, regardless of what race they are.

Anonymous said...

Um..... Resident Evil 5 is made by a Japanese company. So how is it inciting racial tension if the game shows a white man killing black enemies? when the creators are neither black or white.

Anonymous said...

So our solutions to this problem are as follows:

A. Chris, the main protagonist, becomes black, asian, hispanic, non-white, etc. via delayed effects of the T-virus.

B. The game cannot be set in Africa. Better yet, it can only take place in a world where Africa does not exist.

C. Africa exists, but it is populated only by white people.

It seems your view of a truly non-racist game is one that does not recognize that blacks exist.

Anonymous said...

I think you need to do some research before you starting posting such bullshit.

You obviously have ignored all semblence of the context involved. If you took the time to look into the series, its history and in essence what its all about you would see that it has nothing to do with race.

Where was the uproar when resident evil 4 came out? When those who were infected were Spanish there wasnt a peep. Now that they are black there are cues of people lining up just waiting to be offended.

What if the charecter you were controlling was black, shooting white people? Im pretty sure we wouldnt be having this debate. Im glad so many people have come out in defence on this gamem, It shows that when you dont do your research it can blow up in your face.

Go and get yourself a copy of resident evil 4. You get to shoot Spanish guys in that, so you shouldnt get offended.

Anonymous said...

''LOL. I bet that half of you work for the company. You're probably 3 or 4 people commenting over and over again. I've never seen a blog where all the comments sounded so identical.''



yeah... it couldnt be that the points made against this article are SO obvious and SO clearly correct and tangible, that people just feel the want to make ignorant people like you see it too.

Maybe the reason the same point KEEPS coming up, is because there is ACTUALLY some weight to what is being said?

oh and if the writer of the article thinks its the same 4 ppl, then they can check IP adresses of posts and i am certain there will be more than 4 people.

THeres no smoke without fire. Hundreds of people are yelling the SAME points at you because they are so BIG and FUNDAMENTAL to this debate. perhaps you should unplug your ears and listen to them.

If you dont agree with the points fair enough, but post intelligent and well thought out counter-arguments dont just yell 'na na na i cant hear you, i cant hear you!, im not listenting!', it makes you out like a 5 year old.

someone said...

... the silliness of those who claim the 21st century marked the dawn of a post-racial world.
The world will never be post-racial as long as people like you exist, manufacturing controversy when there is none to be found, demanding absurd special treatment and whining about events that took place ages ago.

African-Americans will never make any progress because they choose not to. They'd rather blame all their problems on someone else and expect the world to cater to their every whim and demand, no matter how unreasonable or misinformed.

If you need to blatantly manufacture controversy like this, it's obvious that actual white-on-black racism is long gone.

realityengine said...

this guy needs to lay off the peyote

FishBalls said...

This is the comment I posted on Kotaku



Yelling out "Context!" or "Zombies means this is not racism!", I feel, is not really hitting the point.

Like N'Gai Croal was quoted in the post "...this imagery has a history." Regardless of the context that it is taken from, when the said imagery portrays a white man gunning down Africans, there WILL be a reaction. It's uncomfortable and repulsive at a fundamental level because it brings up memories and ideas (personal and otherwise) from a very ugly time in history.

What bothers me most about this is that at this time, when we are supposed to be as socially advanced as we are, that the majority of the reactions to this imagery can basically be boiled down to two variations of knee-jerkery, one proclaiming racism without consideration, and the other defensively claiming otherwise without understanding.

Anonymous said...

Ooh my goodness, a lot of people here need get an education.

Splinter Cell Double Agent mission 10 is set in Africa with violence around involving blacks. There was no racism outcry. So the point that games can't be set in Africa is then shot down.

So why is RE5 causing controversy? Its not because its set in Africa. Its the IMAGERY of blacks resembling mindless savages that is offending some black people.

Yes they are zombies we know, but blacks have been potrayed as uncivilised babarians and the images of RE5 bring those thoughts back.

Double Agent didnt potray Africans as uncivilised, whilst RE5 does that unwittingly.

Think about it, imagine a game were you were killing Jews? Think about the reaction? It would be complete OUTRAGE.

I love Capcom. SF2 is one of my favourite games of all time, but Cacom would have been better off steering clear of negative potrayal of blacks.

I agree this particular writer is a non gamer. But Ngai Coral a gaming guru shares the same views. Thats why I wish white and other non black gamers could be more understanding as to why some people see this game as racist.

Simba

Anonymous said...

The only people I see getting offended over this are white people who think the black people are angry over it, and racist black people. Yes. Racist black people. It's possible. They can hate white people for no real reason other than a long time ago when some white guys who are now dead did terrible things to their ancestors.

You sir, have done the adult equivalent of a child who falls down and then looks at his/her parents to see if they should be crying or not.

"I should be angry about this white guy killing black people right? Right? Because it's racist isn't it?"

Having an army of black people makes perfect sense. Know why?

1. It's AFRICA. And last time I checked, there were quite a few black people in small African villages.

2. Usually, poor diseased populaces have a pretty high reproductive rate since they have a pretty short lifespan. You can say what you want about that being racist, but I am in no way taking consideration to the color of their skin. I'm just stating scientific fact. Poor areas with a lot of disease (and incidentally little or no birth control) have high reproductive rates, and wealthy areas with less disease have lower reproductive rates. I don't give a crap what color they are. That's just how it works. So that account for the sheer numbers of the zombies.

Conclusion: People who complain about racism in popular culture usually sound the most racist. If I see a horde of crazed zombie-like people coming at me with intent to kill, I either run or kill them first. I don't stop to think "Alright. It's time to clean this place up. It's too DARK in here, if you catch my meaning. Filthy blackies.", nope. Instead I'm probably thinking "Oh crap...SHOOT THEM!" See how there is no mention of skin color in that second one? The people are black because it makes sense for them to be black. Chris is white because it makes absolutely no sense to change his skin color suddenly after he has already been white in other Resident Evil games.

Let skin color go. You're only holding everyone back.

the genius within said...

d'uh..i'm proudly african and have been playing video games since i was 8. I've played the previous iterations of Resident evil namely 1 and 2 on the sony playstation 1 and i had fun killing zombies.

Fine, its set in a fictional african location, and believe me, it at least shows some recognition of the continent in video game circles.

I'm buying the game for my sony ps3 and i'm gonna have fun killing the zombies.

Its just that, a video game, a work of someone's creativity.

Lets not even bring the word 'racism' into it please. There are so many things wrong in africa today, ala zimbabwe, southern african killings, these we should focus on to help the continent get its act together.

Not a video game that many of my african brothers probably would never get to play cos they cant afford to. Sounds harsh, but that is the stark reality really.

One love, brother..lol

Lucy said...

Tolu Olorunda, you sir are the biggest ignorant I have ever heard of. You have not done any research what so ever on this topic, not looked at previous titles in the series and in doing so you have insulted many black gamers for your (ironically) racist remarks.

I find it Ironic you complain about a video game, but where is your complaint about Jay Z and the use of the word Nigger that's in almost every song, likewise 50 Cent. They sing it so much that the word has simply lost its meaning now, why would any Black person call themselves that? Yet if a white person says it casually, hes a racist, pot calling kettle black...

Anonymous said...

"So why is RE5 causing controversy? Its not because its set in Africa. Its the IMAGERY of blacks resembling mindless savages that is offending some black people.

Yes they are zombies we know, but blacks have been potrayed as uncivilised babarians and the images of RE5 bring those thoughts back."



That argument might hold some water if Resident Evil had been made by a company where the majority of employees/employers were white.
But its made by a Japanese company. And most Japanese would not familiar with racial imagery, or might have a vague idea of it. The imagery of black people being "mindless savages" is an imagery that was created by whites.
It's not something that a Japanese company would even think about, let alone know much about.

In the end all Capcom wants to do is make a good game and please their fans. Is that so bad?

Anonymous said...

"The trailer featured a Caucasian male mutilating African villages, along with African ZOMBIES."


I fixed your error Tolu.

Daniel Griffin said...

i am sorry but you really are talking shite. have you never played a resident evil game? All resident evil games contain creatures that are normally barbaric and savage. In all the other games there have been different races. the first few were set in the US and most of the creatures were caucasian. The forth one contained hispanic creatures; still no one got pissed off or acused anyone of racism. Then finally they base the location in Africa (as far as im aware) and a rant about racism sparks up just because it contains white guys shooting black guys?

Was there any rants about GTA:San Andres when the main character, a black american, was shooting every race he could find?

i think not.

just get over it, its a video game for christ sake.

seriously people, wake up.

someone said...

anonymous:
So why is RE5 causing controversy? Its not because its set in Africa. Its the IMAGERY of blacks resembling mindless savages that is offending some black people.


Well thank God the Spaniards in RE4 weren't portrayed as savages or anything!

Yes they are zombies we know, but blacks have been potrayed as uncivilised babarians and the images of RE5 bring those thoughts back.

When I saw RE5's trailer for the first time the race angle didn't even occur to me. That's probably because I don't spend every waking hour deconstructing reality to find racist conspiracies.

Double Agent didnt potray Africans as uncivilised, whilst RE5 does that unwittingly.

I'd like to see someone get outraged over the real uncivilized activity going on in Africa.

Think about it, imagine a game were you were killing Jews? Think about the reaction? It would be complete OUTRAGE.

It's not the same. Jews are a very small and very specific subset of people, blacks are not.

I love Capcom. SF2 is one of my favourite games of all time, but Cacom would have been better off steering clear of negative potrayal of blacks.

Fuck that. No game developer should cowtow to the irrational demands of people who manufacture controversy out of thin air. "Racism" will never end as long as people like this blogger are taken seriously.

Anonymous said...

YOU MEAN I GET TO SHOOT WAVES UPON WAVES OF NEGROS, AS A WHITE POLICEMAN! SWEET! WHEN DOES THIS GAME RELEASE?

Anonymous said...

The VIRUS is genocide. The killing spree is zombiecide.

Anonymous said...

This is the most ridiculous post I've ever read. Do some damn research and use your brain before bashing something.

CitizenLand said...

Another black racist who can't wait to continue the legacy of victimhood.

Congrats, black on black murder, poverty, illiteracy, hunger continue unabated in the black community but you make damn sure that you nail whitey on every little slip-up that you can comfortably sit back and type your vitriol about.

Be a man and get off your anonymous ass and do something other than playing PC police. Your own desire to remain a victim is holding you back far more than any actual or perceived racism is.

Anonymous said...

I'm gonna disect this whole thing, all while making food, so if it comes out weird, its because I'm cooking at the same time.



"What I witnessed [in the RE5 trailer] was nerve-wrecking, painful, mind-numbing and heart-racing... It wasted no time in capitalizing upon the long history of blatant depictions of Africans as savages and helpless imbeciles. The trailer featured a Caucasian male mutilating African villages, along with Africans. With the not-so ancient history of colonialism and neo-colonialism in Africa, the issue of racial insensitivity and indifference must be brought to the centerfold..."



'long history of blatant depictions of Africans as savafes and helpless imbeciles'.

To be fair, they acted (and still do to today) with a degree of savagery unfound in any other part of the world. True, in the big cities they are cultured and intelligent, but in the villages they are often very savage people.

That isn't to say that they're not still good people. Look at the values found in African villages, values that you can't find in many of the families that descended from that part of the world today. Honor, Loyalty, Respect.

'The trailer featured a Caucasian male mutilating African villages, along with Africans'

Really? Where do you see him mutilating a village or its inhabitants? Could it be you're just trying to make things up to make a splash, eh?

Once again, the game is made by japanese people who have never had a problem with slavery or colonialism. Maybe the Author of this article should hop off of his soap box long enough to do some fucking research, but that would probably make it harder for him to make his oh-so politically correct and assinine statement.



Someone should ask the author about other industries that have made profit off the 'black on black casualty', like the movie industry, the music industry, and BET. Honestly, this author needs to pull his head out of his ass and get a real job, not just sit around trying to find racism where there is none. And people wonder why racism is still alive and well; it's people like the author.

«Oldest ‹Older   1 – 200 of 206   Newer› Newest»

Blog Archive